I pulled out four more episode titles from my trusty Tupperware container and put my thoughts on each.
What are your thoughts on the following episodes?
Is it a scene, a moment, a line or song?
And why? It is your favourite or is it the emotional impact it has on you?
Maybe it simply makes you laugh or hide under the covers.

 
Shadow

For this episode the first scene I think of is the reunion with their Dad. The look on both boys faces when John turns to them with his ‘Hi boys”. And how Dean just walks right up to John to hug him. No anger, no ‘where the hell have you’ve been?’ just with relief and love.

Shadowhug

And then after a few awkward words Sam and John hug each other.

Shadowhug2
 
Tall Tales

This is one of my favourite episodes. As devious as the Trickster was, I just loved him and all the episodes he was in, well maybe with the exception of "Hammer of the Gods." I’m still bitter over his death.

For this one I can’t give just one moment, I‘m just going to mention the moments that I loved. First the whole bar scene, with the Purple Nurples and Sam’s bitchface along with his ‘Bla bla bla.’

PrissySam

Secondly the boys wrestling over the money clip.

Thirdly Dean stuffing his face with chocolates and looking like a chipmunk.

215Supernatural0392

Fourthly Sammy getting all emotional with the missing boys roommate.

And finally I have to go with Bobby’s WTF expression when the boys are telling their different interpretations.  â€œAlien’s????”
 
My Bloody Valentine

This is one of those episodes where there were so many powerful and memorable moments that it makes it almost impossible to choose just one. We have the couple eating each other to death, the huggable Cupid, Mr. McHappy Meal Castiel. There is Sam’s realization that he can’t go with Dean to confront Famine as his hunger for Demon blood is overtaking him and with Dean now having to put him in lockdown in the bathroom. Dean’s confrontation with Famine, being told he is empty inside that he is dead already. Sam’s feasting on the two boneheaded demons that thought it was a good idea to release him. ”Wait your turn!”

SPN 1050

And there’s Sam’s triumphant defeat of Famine with his powers.

However if I had to choose it would be the end scene. Just when you thought this episode couldn’t rip at your heart any further we get an ending that not only goes for the jugular, but tears away what’s left of our hearts. Sam is detoxing in the panic room with Castiel and Dean standing outside the door. Sam is screaming their name, begging for their help while Dean drinks directly from a Whisky bottle. Cas tries to comfort Dean with his “That’s not him in there, not really.” And “Dean, Sam just has to get it out of his system.” However Sam’s screams are just too much for Dean and he leaves to get some air. Outside Dean walks over to the Impala and looks up with tears in his eyes pleads “Please, I can’t…I need some help. Please?”

SPN 1265
 
My Heart Will Go On

With this episode I always think of the moment when Fate confronts Castiel about re-sinking the Titanic. Fate has frozen time and is preventing a huge HVAC unit from landing on top of Sam and Dean, meanwhile Balthazar is sneaking up behind Fate.

MH112

Cas: Balthazar stop!
Fate turns around to see Balthazar ready to kill her with a knife.
Balthazar: Ah! Awkward!
Fate: Set things right before I flick your precious boys off a cliff just on principle.
Balthazar: Sweetie before we go I could remove that stick from your….
Fate: Don’t try me!
Balthazar: We’ll leave it inserted then.

This scene makes me laugh every time I see it.

What are your favorite scenes from these episodes?