Largest Review/Discussion Fansite for Supernatural and SPNFamily Shows! Plot/Character Analysis, Spoilers, Games, News, Gallery, Interviews, Fun!
Thoughts on Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid
Ah, Thursday night - at last you return with my Supernatural fix. I settled in with my tea, ready to continue on the Apocalyptic adventure with the Winchesters. But wait, what's this? A basketball game? That can't be right! Sadly, it was. Yes, the first new Supernatural episode in months was pre-empted by a basketball game. I was not impressed. So after waiting all this time, I had to wait another day for someone to get the episode online. This morning with my morning coffee and breakfast, I sat down to enjoy the gruesomeness that was Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid.
Most of this episode was sombre and sad from start to finish. You couldn't really rejoice at the return of the deceased loved ones because you knew there had to be a catch. And boy was there. The episode did have it's funny moments - such as when Sam and Dean's FBI boss-phone trick backfired. And who didn't love Sam's exchange with old zombie woman, the expressions on his face throughout that scene were priceless. Sadness was the primary theme running through this episode. Bobby's misery over his wife and her death. The sheriff rallying herself together after watching her newly undead son devour her husband (and who won't be haunted by the shot of the bloody-mouthed tot in PJ's for days to come?). Bobby's wife herself, recognizing that she was unnatural, trying to play the happy wife and pretend she didn't know Bobby had killed her. There was even something tragic in the simple idea that Dean has never been in love - because it's true. Yes, this episode was riddled with melancholic moments.
I have a few issues with this episode, specifically as the first out the gate episode after such a long hiatus. We're going into the back end of the season and I'd hoped for something a little more myth-heavy than this episode. We were left in such a raw place after My Bloody Valentine, with Sam locked in the panic room detoxing and Dean pleading to anyone who will listen to help him. This episode didn't really touch on that. Bobby as a target for Team Lucifer wasn't really a surprise, was it? I mean, he's helping our boys maintain their anti-apocalypse, no-way-are-we-consenting-to-be-vessels stance; of course they want to knock him out the way or at least down a few pegs on the moral support pole.
What did work about this episode was the incredible performance of Jim Beaver. Bobby's turmoil was understated and beautifully executed. As viewers, we really felt for him. One of the saddest scenes was Bobby talking about his wife humming, which is a tight second only to the tears in Bobby's eyes as he shoots Dean the most devastated expression after having killed his wife for a second time. Finally, the ending in which Sam's question to Bobby - you'll be alright? - was left hanging in the air with a vacant look on Bobby's face that suggests, no, he probably won't be okay for a good long while.
There were also a few subtleties in this episode that I appreciated. Sam's look at Dean's tired expression as Bobby tells the boys another horseman has run amok. This minute exchange really tells us how close to the edge Dean is - and, more importantly, how aware of that Sam is. Also, I wasn't sure whether to be amused that Bobby was considered the town drunk, or concerned. On one hand, I wondered if that wasn't part of his "cover" to keep people away and give him an excuse for any "weird" behaviour that he might engage in as a hunter. On the other hand, however, I wondered if this was a recent label that Bobby'd earned himself since landing in the wheelchair. After tonight's episode it's clear Bobby isn't in a good place and, like Dean, I wonder how much longer he can hold on.
Sam was a great take-charger in this episode. From his encounter with the first-to-rot zombie to his dealing with the sheriff's creepy son, Sam seems to have bounced back quite nicely from his demon-blood binge the last time we saw him. Perhaps the relapse was a monkey off his back - yes, he relapsed - through no fault of his own- as he feared he would, but he also got clean again, so maybe this has renewed his strength.
Overall, this episode was subdued and sombre - not quite the bold, apocalyptic episode I'd anticipated fresh of a hiatus - but I kind of enjoyed it all the same. Now, next week's episode - well the trailer alone makes me quiver so I've no doubt the episode itself will be incredible. All in all, the most important thing about this episode? The end of Hellatus! Thank goodness the Hellatus is over and we've got a straight shot to the end now! Welcome back, Winchesters, welcome back.


# AndreaW 2010-03-26 12:02
Elle, it seems that this episode whas shot before MBV so Sam still hadn't had his problem with the demon blood yet. That also explains why this episode didn't touch the events in MBV.
# AndreaW 2010-03-26 14:22
Ops. Typing mistakes detected. Sorry! :oops:
# Randal 2010-03-27 11:51
I wonder when exactly they knew this was airing after 5.14, because they could have filmed something for "continuity" purposes. I keep thinking about the X-Files and how in Leonard Betts, it's now obvious that Scully has cancer, then they aired Never Again, THEN the big cancer ep. But I'm willing to let that slide because it was such a good episode, much personal angst for Bobby and it was shot really well.
# elle 2010-03-27 13:36
I didn't realize the episodes were shot out of sequence with the way they aired - haven't been as up on my fandom reading of late. It does explain a lot - and if it had aired in order, Sam's pushing of Dean to talk in MBV would have been further highlighted. Any idea why they aired out of order?
# Tigershire 2010-03-27 15:49
Well, if they had aired the episodes in order, and started the hiatus at the same time, MBV would have been the episode we just saw and not the cliffhanger it got to be.

Likely the reason TPTB changed the order. But I'm just guessing.
# Deborah 2010-03-27 17:13
I read somewhere that the order was changed just because the network wanted "My Bloody Valentine" to air closer to Valentine's day. Not sure if that's truly the reason, but it's a lame enough one that I would believe the CW would use it.
# immie_8 2010-03-30 23:51
@Deborah - What seems to have happened is that for the November-Decemb er hiatus, The CW seemed to have been planning to bring SN back one week earlier (Jan. 14th as opposed to the 21st when it actually did return), which would have allowed MBV to be aired as the 15th episode, and still air on the Thursday before Valentine's Day. The decision to bring the show back later, while still wanting to put it on hiatus due to the Olympics, meant that either MBV needed to air as the 14th episode (instead of 15 as originally planned) or it would be aired long after Valentine's Day. It seems like whoever had the final say opted to go with the former and switch the order. It really does suck, as the continuity goes straight through the window - especially as this episode was also shot before MBV, but c'est la vie. *sigh*

I actually can't wait until next week's episode, as that's where the real fallout should be seen! :D