“The Mentalists” Review:  Sibling Acts Are Tough

“The Mentalists” Review: Sibling Acts Are Tough

The Mentalists starts with Sam and Dean separated after the revelation that Dean had killed Amy behind Sam’s back. A week and a half later finds both brothers drawn to Lily Dale, due to the strange murders of mediums. Unlike previous episodes where the brothers are repairing a rift, the tension is an undercurrent through…

Alice’s Review – “The Mentalists” Plus What’s Wrong With Sam and Dean?

Alice’s Review – “The Mentalists” Plus What’s Wrong With Sam and Dean?

These reviews are getting so tough anymore.  As a constructive reviewer trying to be honest in a critical realm, the job is to take any new material you’ve been given and tie it all together with everything prior.  It really sucks when you have to do that for an episode that by itself was decent,…

What I Learned From “Shut Up Dr. Phil” and Salute To Supernatural Chicago

What I Learned From “Shut Up Dr. Phil” and Salute To Supernatural Chicago

(I promise, not a lot of negativity here.)   I actually find the serviceable, average episode to be the hardest to write reviews for.  There really isn’t much to say.  It didn’t suck.  It wasn’t “Bugs” (that was my Twitter review for the week).  I laughed a few times.  I scratched my head a few…

“Shut Up Dr. Phil” Review: Metaphors and Parallels

“Shut Up Dr. Phil” Review: Metaphors and Parallels

Metaphors and parallels have run through Supernatural throughout its existence. The episode “Scarecrow” is a metaphor about the so-called apple pie life and how it isn’t everything as it’s cracked up to be. “Heart” and “Metamorphosis” are metaphors for Sam’s growing destiny. Castiel’s season 6 trajectory parallels Sam in season 4. Dean’s attempt to live…

“Defending Your Life” Review:  “We’re Not Catholic”

“Defending Your Life” Review: “We’re Not Catholic”

“We’re not Catholic.”   “Defending Your Life,” may have featured an Egyptian God, but the guilt contained within is clearly of the Catholic variety.   Dean is put on trial here, by Osiris, who will then weigh his guilt. Dean carries an awful lot of it around indeed, but most of it is misplaced and…