Can you believe we're kicking off another season already?  Those of us in the TV Fanatic "Supernatural" roundtable - myself, Nightsky, and Sean Mc Kenna and Christine and Laskodi of TV Fanatic, were all stunned that we were kicking off season 12!  
The season premiere gave us plenty to talk about.  What did we think of Mary's story?  What's up with the British Men of Letters and what is Toni's real motive? Lucifer was also part of the discussion, mainly speculation about him next week.  It all is here:
Here's Sean McKenna's review.  He didn't enjoy the premiere as much as others, finding it a little lackluster.  He only gave it a 3.7 out of 5.0.