Best MacGyver Moment

Sam making and using his own stun gun.
Best Guest Actor Scene(s)

The Reaper Billie played by Lisa Berry. I loved her powerful performance from her beautiful but eerie version of "O' Death" to her informing Sam that there will be no more resurrections nor a place in Heaven for him and Dean.
Best Crowley Line(s)

As usual Crowley had some great one lines.
'Hello my son'
'After I finish my tea'
'I'm sorry agent pathetic rock star'
'I was getting bored.'
Best VFX scene
I chose two scenes that I thought were very well done.

The blocks flying above Amara and then being whipped into the wall...

to form the words 'Feed Me',

and Sam's visions of being tortured back in the PIT.
Best Sam Moment

Sam praying, not for himself but for Dean and for hope. "And if I have to die, I made my peace with that. But please Dean deserves better. Dean deserves a life."
Best Dean Moment

Dean being handed baby Amara and reassuring her "Hey beautiful." Such a paternal moment.
Best Musical Cue

"Oh Death" being sung as the Reaper Billie takes the soul of the newest victim
Scariest Moment

Even though I knew something was going to happen when Sam reached down for the pudding, it still made me jump as he became face to face with his captive.
"Liar! You and me, we're dead. We're just taking our sweet time about it, so if you were smart you'd put a bullet in me and then one in you."
Grossest Moment

Sam's flashback of the PIT. Anything with eyes... EEEWWWWWW!
Best Bad Ass Moment

Cas getting all dog and killing Efram and Jonah.
Saddest Moment

Cas realising that Hannah is playing him.
Creepiest Moment

Crowley offering up the 'Mini Van Family' to Amara. "Want some candy little girl?"

And Amara accepting the offer with just a creepy smile.
I hope you enjoyed this week's "Memorable Moments" review! Please share what your picks would be for these categories, or offer categories of your own!
Comments
I agree, Sam in the chapel was a great scene. In fact the whole Sam, in the hospital set, storyline, and guest stars was great!
Thanks Karen for the recaps, well done.
I also laughed at your LSOH reference. I haven't seen that movie in over 20years. Thank you so much for your comments.
I'm so happy you're enjoying these. I don't know how the CGI works whether they actually have to do anything to his eyes, if they do I also feel bad for him.
Agreed that Sam got the best part of his episode all around though, his prayer, his conversation with Billie (I hope we see her again) his vision and his smarts.....yeah ! Sammy for the win! He really deserved that definitive win didn't he? Yeah.
I thought I saw something with the baby's face changing but I couldn't find any screencaps at the time, otherwise I would have had that as well.
Sammy for the Win! Definitely on board with that. :) Thank you for your comments.
I have to laugh because I thought the same thing. Why are the women tortured naked but not the men. I guess being shirtless the most the J's are willing to do. Which I have no problem with.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
- Lilah
I always have to look away for anything with the eyes or anything mucus/vomit related.
Most grateful moment because it is happy to hear Sam and Dean get a thank you for their work once in a while.
Great choices! I agree it was nice to have both Sam and Dean being thanked for their work. Thanks for sharing.