Dean Wins Rock Paper Scissors - this has been a series long thing (obviously) and was funny to watch since Dean finally won, so excited at such he didn't claim the prize (I believe J&J talk about this in a con video). AND it truly is an inside joke, since I read a review of this episode on EW.com where the reviewer asked what she was missing in the RPS game because she didn't get the joke - obviously not someone watching from the start (which begs the question: what kind of people are they letting review our show?!). In short, a great nod to long time and/or devoted viewers.
"Don't Call Me Shurley"
"Oh, I've been super busy. Yeah, I traveled. I started a blog. Mostly just pictures of cats. They're so cute. And, uh -- Oh, I signed up for Snapchat! And I started a new series of books. Revolution. But I don't think it's going anywhere."
Yep, Eric Kripke's post SPN series "Revolution" was cancelled at NBC after two seasons. It literally went nowhere.
Series Long Myth Put to Rest
This sort of/kind of falls under this category since it's been around all series in one way or another: Did Sam or did he not pick up the Amulet, all those years ago? YES!
Best Appearance By A Supposedly Important Figure That Didn’t Go Anywhere
Billie the Reaper
A constant threat that ultimately culminated in nothing. Yes, she technically pulled out the souls for the bomb, but even that ended in a puff and fizzle since it never came to fruition. Awful lot of talk through the season, and the character certainly had the air of power and threat about her....and then nothing.
Coming up next, the third part of our awards, aka a bunch of other misc categories we missed. After all, it's a 23 episode season. There's a lot to recognize!
Miss the Supernatural Season 11 Fan Choice Awards?