“The Heroes’ Journey” was certainly an interesting episode. As far as timing goes, it was a dose of levity after so much angst and turmoil. That said, this episode left me with mixed feelings overall  in spite of the laughter and effervescent presence of DJ Qualls’ Garth.

The Morning After

On the surface, Supernatural’s “The Heroes’ Journey” was a hilarious break in the intensity of the brothers' lives, watching Sam and Dean fumble and bumble around like two extremely uncoordinated buffoons in a bunker! It was also a delightful goodbye to Garth, who got to save the day and live happily ever after with his wife, three children and beautiful home, complete with a successful dental practice in the basement.   The underlying message of the episode was depressingly different, however. In fact, it was so defeating that I’m going to pack it away in the trunk of Baby until the end of this review. So let’s talk about the happy first!

THEN:  Chuck says, "I hate missing my favorite show."  The Winchesters kill monsters.  Lots of killing.  Dean says, "We're the guys who saved the world."  We see Garth with his werewolf wife.  Chuck says, "You still think you're the hero of this story."  He destroys their spell and says, "That was just the beginning.  This is the rest."  

NOW:  A young bearded man with a slightly bloody face is staring straight at the camera.  He is hit in the jaw and collapses to the floor.  He's in a ring, surrounded by cheering people, but the sound is muted, reflecting his dazed reaction to the blow he just took.  A slim young woman with long dreads in a ponytail swaggers around the ring, taunting him.  He gets to his feet and swings, but she ducks, baring her teeth aggressively, confidently.  The man is beaten to the ground again.  His eyes flare yellowy-gold; his teeth extend.  With a roar he jumps to his feet and claws at her side, drawing blood.  How could she win against a werewolf?  But then, a long, sharp spike descends from her wrist; she's a monster too, a wraith, armed and lethal as well.  The music has incongruously changed to pleasant piano music as the two creatures fiercely battle.  Surrounding them, the audience avidly cheer, many showing teeth identifying them as monsters as well.  Eventually, the wraith prevails.  The werewolf collapses forward onto the floor while his opponent prances triumphantly around the ring.   At a distance from the crowd, a shadowed figure is seated, watching.  Inside the cage the werewolf lies still, his face against a grate in the floor, while his blood obscures our view.

Everything we know about Supernatural season 15 episode 10.
I've been processing this episode for almost a week, and I'm still kind of struggling to figure out what I think. We'll go with what I know first and then try and unpack what I'm not so certain of.

Um…err…well…oh crap. 

Who am I kidding?  There are 11 episodes of “Supernatural” left and at this point, I would like to watch episodes I actually enjoy.  When I look at the construction and intent of “The Trap” from a writer’s perspective, I see what was supposed to happen.  On paper, it could be perceived as downright clever.  It raises some interesting questions, like what would happen if the light of God wasn’t in the world?  Can God be inherently evil?  Is trapping God being done for the benefit of the world or because Sam and Dean don’t like being rats in his maze?  All good questions.   

Why then was this episode a total hot mess?  This wasn’t fun to watch in the least.  This is not my heroes’ journey.