The long Hellatus is upon us once again.  This year, Karen and I have a great way to help you entertain yourself while waiting for the season premiere!  Karen has taken screencaps from various "Supernatural" episodes, the two of us have come up with alternative dialogue for that moment, and I've turned them into captions!  Karen's are the top in each pair, and mine are on the bottom.  We're posting two rounds a week, 10 captions in all, so come back every Monday and Thursday to check out our captions and post yours in the comments sections.

1.


2.

3.

4.

5.

Your turn!  Tell us your favorites and give us your best captions!

 

Comments  

Mickey
# Mickey 2012-05-24 12:27
Love all of yours!

My brain is not cooperating at the moment. I keep looking at the pics and seeing your captions and not coming up with anything as good. I'll try again later.
Sylvie
# Sylvie 2012-05-24 12:47
Ooh, this is going to be fun. Loved your caps, here are some of my own.

Pic one: He said WHAT?
Pic two: I do the best blue steel
No, I do
Pic three: Did you just fart?
Pic four: If there are any left, I'm taking them with me
Pic five: Oh, man, why can't I get a big man cup?
suzee51
# suzee51 2012-05-24 14:26
Pic #1: You seriously think Stefan and Damon are better looking?

Pic #2: Is it "tweet" or "twit"?

Pic #3: Really not all that interested in driving through Stars Hollow.

Pic #4: This is really making me hungry for some pie. Gotta get me some pie!

Pic #5: I wonder if some day I'll go to Hell for this disguise . . .
fanotheboyz
# fanotheboyz 2012-05-24 20:10
1 "We'll have to drive a.....Pinto?"

2 "Dude, did you switch mugs on me again?"

3 "Nah, I don't need a shower; maybe a haircut. Just a little off the bangs..."

4 "I wonder if these are made from ground Turducken?"

5 "Careful....don 't....break...t he....china"
rmoats8621
# rmoats8621 2012-05-25 00:42
1. "Really. I can't believe you just said that!"

2. "Do I have a "got milk" mustache?"

3. "Man that stinks! Did you just fart?"

4. "These are so good. I could eat a dozen more."

5. "I would love a real mug instead of this prissy cup."
B_Y_O
# B_Y_O 2012-05-25 03:37
1. Sam, the menu is in French. What’s ‘la cervelle’?
2. I have reflexes so fast; I just caught a fly . It’s here now, buzzing around in between my clenched hands . Any second now , I could crush the fly. Fear me. I am Dean Winchester.
3. . … And once, Jess suggested we do this thing she found in a sex manual and I’m like, no freaking way…
4. Oh God, I think I just stabbed my own tongue with a tooth pick.
5. Remember, Sam. Hold the pinky finger out.
sylvia37
# sylvia37 2012-05-25 08:24
#1 You want to do what to my brother?

#2 What do you think, should I let her?

#3 It wasn't as bad as I thought it would be.

#4 I ...just have....a little piece stuck.....

#5 Now if I just .....set.. the cup.... on top. There! My china pyramid is done.
Gwen
# Gwen 2012-05-25 09:15
What a fun game. :-) Great pics and caps, Ardeospina and Karen.

1. What?? Who won Next Top Model?? No way!

2. 'You might do the best bitchface, Sam, but my pout face is AWESOME!

3. Well, that psychic is crazy. She said next year I won't have my bangs anymore...

4. If anyone...anyone...goes near that pie by there I'm going to shoot them with rock salt.

5. Now, how did that 'make the tea cup disappear' trick I used to know start ....
Reetu
# Reetu 2012-05-25 09:16
Hi Aredo, gr8 fun exercise. Your caps are wonderful hilarious

1) Sorry who? Who look more cool dude?
2) Sam: Jerk Dean: Bitch. See we both can speak with pouts and look cool.
3) What are you doing dean, it stinks :-x
4) Oh the lady could have served the Pie instead..
5) Do you have bigger cups? :lol:

I know i suck at these but i loved this fun game.Thanks again..
FMJemena
# FMJemena 2012-05-29 00:56
For #3: "Nah! That's not mine. Sure smells really bad, though."
FMJemena
# FMJemena 2012-05-29 00:59
For #4 and #5 -- can't think of anything else, just have my thoughts when I looked at the pictures:

#4 -- *how fast can I beat Dean to those sausages?*
# 5 -- sighs. what a handsome priest Sam makes
Tim the Enchanter
# Tim the Enchanter 2012-06-02 03:48
1. Dean: 'So we’re going to end up in hell, bring about the Apocalypse, house Lucifer, release Leviathans into the world, be bff’s with a fallen angel, have pizza with Death, Dad's going to become a celestial ball of twinkling light, I’m going to have a daughter that Sam will gank and Sam will sleep with a werewolf. Wait, wait, Sam’s gonna have sex??'

Sam: (thinks) 'I'm gonna have sex. Sweet...'

(Jeez, Sam looks so incredibly, scarily sweet and young in that first picture! I almost feel like a dirty old woman putting 'sex' and 'Sam' in the same sentence. Course then I remember 2.17 and 6.03 and I get over it pretty damn quickly!)

2. Dean: 'Okay Sam, I’ve taught you about girls and I’ve taught you about guns now it's time I taught you about make up. First up, lipstick. Okay, pout your lips. No, no, pout them, don’t pucker them. If you pucker you’ll get bleed lines and girls don't like those.'

3. Sam: 'So I’ll sleep with a demon and a werewolf and most of the women I end up in bed with will die. But I will get to have sex with them first, right? Well okay then.'

4: 'So this is how you kill demonic mini wieners. They can be destroyed by the power of enamel and saliva. I'd better put this into Dad's journal'

5: 'Forget that demon killing malarkey. I'm going to focus all my powers on levitating teacups into my hand.'