Article Index

Welcome to Part 3 of our (spoiler free!) photographic examination of Supernatural’s beloved character, Bobby Singer (to catch up on Bobby’s story, start with Part 1: Creating Bobby’s Character). To recap what has been covered so far, Bobby’s character was introduced to the Supernatural series at the end of its first season. Season 2 developed Bobby’s roles as a father figure to the Winchester brothers, an experienced hunter, and a researcher for supernatural and mythological creatures. Seasons 3 and 4 then expanded Bobby’s character by providing more of his personal history, his history with the Winchester family and his history as a hunter. By the end of the first four seasons, Bobby was a cornerstone of the Supernatural story! This conclusion looks at how seasons 5-8 enriched, changed and expanded Bobby’s story in ways that were sometimes wonderful and sometimes shocking, but always interesting!

Enjoy! – Nightsky


image1

7.06 “Slash Fiction” – Bobby’s roles expanded, literally and figuratively!

Bobby Presence in the Story

The first four seasons of Supernatural celebrated a resourceful, sarcastic, wise old hunter named Bobby Singer. Bobby’s character, masterfully portrayed by Jim Beaver, quickly evolved into one of the most loved characters of the series. Surprisingly, Bobby only appeared in 20 episodes in these early years (approximately one third of the 67 episodes that aired after he was introduced). Acknowledging the inner-geek that analyses the dynamics of a character’s development (sorry, this will only take a minute…), Bobby’s character was concentrated in the “bookends” of each season, i.e. the opening and closing episodes. Surprisingly, he was only seen two or three times in the middle of each season!

Bobbygraph1

As a testament to Jim’s talent, Bobby’s value to the story and his popularity with the fans steadily grew, until he was used in half of the episodes in seasons 5, 6 and 7! 

Number of Appearances Each Season:

Bobbygraph2

Even though the number of Bobby’s episodes increased as the show’s story matured, the pattern of when he appeared remained the same, i.e. heavily at the beginning and end of each season, and sporadically in the middle.

Bobbygraph3


Dialog references (e.g. “I just spoke with Bobby”) and one-sided phone conversations were frequently used to make it seem like Bobby was always involved in the storyline, but Jim, in fact, remained a “guest star” on the series. (Okay, geeky analytics concluded. Sorry, I found that interesting…)

Evolving Traits in Bobby’s Character

In the first few years of the show, Bobby was meticulously depicted as a father figure to the brothers, an extraordinary researcher of lore and an accomplished hunter. Seasons 3 and 4 had also carefully introduced vulnerability, human flaws and a complicated past into Bobby’s character. The series’ later seasons continued to develop these roles and character traits, bringing some of them to their ultimate conclusion: 

Father Figure

In the very first episode of season 5, Bobby’s love for “his boys” was used to set up one of the most poignant scenes of the series.  Possessed by a demon and ordered to kill Dean, Bobby’s love enabled him to overthrow the demon’s control and stab himself rather than harm Dean.  Bobby’s choice and willpower precipitated one of the most significant changes in his character (discussed later) and more importantly, foreshadowed the season’s gut-wrenching climax.

image2

5.01 “Sympathy for the Devil” - Out of love for Dean, Bobby seriously wounds himself rather than hurt Dean 

Also in this episode, Bobby reaffirmed his love for Sam, assuring him, “I ain’t cutting you out, boy. Not ever.”  Bobby again risked his life and endured great pain to save both of his boys in “Frontierland” (6.18), when he allowed Castiel to tap into his soul to bring Sam and Dean back from the past.  So there could be no doubt as to his dedication to the brothers.

While the early seasons implied and developed a fatherly connection between Bobby and the brothers, the later seasons evolved the relationship into a more comfortable, accepted and adoptive family bond. In “Appointment in Samarra” (6.11), Sam used Bobby in a spell that required paternal blood, signifying that Bobby now filled the fatherly role fully and completely for Sam.   In “Death’s Door” (7.10), Bobby returned the sentiment, telling his reaper “they’re my boys!”.  Earlier expressions of love had always been “like family” or ‘like a father” (e.g. in “Dream a Little Dream of Me” Dean told Bobby “I’m not gonna let you die. You’re like a father to me.”). In the emotional exposition of “Death’s Door”, though, Bobby said he saved his best memory for last - a memory of “his boys” teasing each other. From the moment Sam and Dean reappeared on his doorstep, these three people had endured apocalyptic hardships, emotional losses and triumphs that strengthened their bonds into a true family. 

Researcher and Hunter

By the beginning of season 5, Bobby’s formidable skills as a researcher had “saved the day” so many times his knowledge was now an indispensable component of almost every hunt. In “Abandon All Hope” (5.10), Bobby deciphered clues and determined that raising Death, the horseman, was the cause of the town’s demon activity. In season 6, Bobby taught the boys about Skinwalkers, dragons and the Mother of All, Eve. Since Bobby had extensive skills as both a researcher and a hunter, though, his assistance often now alternated between providing “behind the scenes” help and joining the team in the field.  Late in season 5, Bobby committed everything he had to the cause when he followed in Dean’s footsteps and sold his soul, in his case to gain critical information to avert the apocalypse (i.e. the location of the last horseman). He was on the team that attacked the warehouse where the Croatoan virus was stored and he later fulfilled his “all in” commitment by sacrificing his life in a vain attempt to stop Lucifer with a bullet. Seasons 6 and 7 included him fighting Khan Worms, Eve, Crowley, vampires and ominously, Leviathans. He was never portrayed as a fifth-wheel or a hunter past his prime. On the contrary, he was respected and always equally contributed to or in some cases surpassed Sam and Dean (they were pretty impressed when he shot a zombie out of a tree by aiming at the sound!). His vast hunter network also continued to add to the story, significantly introducing the boys to Frank Devereux. Bobby’s research and hunting prowess grew in importance and significance to the story, culminating in the ultimate categorization from Sam in “The Slice Girls” (7.13) as a “crazy, drunk, old genius”. Quite a compliment for a character that initially appeared to be a recluse buried in the dust of a lot of old books!

Vulnerable Bobby

Season 5 continued to explore the vulnerability that had been introduced into Bobby’s character in the prior two seasons.  Almost as a reminder of Bobby’s helplessness in “Dream a Little Dream of Me”, season five’s first episode “Sympathy for the Devil” put Bobby back into a hospital bed, this time immobile from physical vs. mental injuries. The parallel images connected the two timelines.

image3
image4

5.01 “Sympathy for the Devil” - Bobby back in hospital after stabbing himself

The next time we saw Bobby, he had been transformed into the “injured warrior”, confined to a wheel chair from his stabbing wound.

image5

5.03 “Free to Be You and Me” – Bobby contemplating his new role as a hunter confined to a wheel chair

Bobby’s despondence and abrupt physical confinement diminished his image as untouchable and indestructible, and suggested the he might not always be the brothers’ emotional or physical refuge. Following through on this theme, Bobby’s depression triggered another degradation of his character only a few weeks later.  In “The Curious Case of Dean Winchester” (5.07) Bobby’s age was accelerated by 25 years, literally and symbolically compromising his strength even further. 

image6

5.07 “The Curious Case of Dean Winchester” – Bobby aged 25 years, and was more vulnerable than ever before

In this episode, Bobby confessed that he had felt useless since being injured and had contemplated suicide because he couldn’t hunt anymore. To dramatize his limited accessibility, Bobby could only continually call Dean’s name as Dean lay dying of a heart attack in the adjacent high rise apartment. Dean’s response at the end of the episode reestablished Bobby’s role in the hunt, though:

5.07

Dean: “…You’re not useless, Bobby.”

Bobby:   “Okay.  Good Talk.” 

Dean:   “No, wait a minute. Listen to me.  You don’t stop being a soldier ‘cause you got wounded in battle. Okay? No matter what shape you’re in, bottom line is, you’re family. I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but me and Sam, we don’t have much left. I can’t do this without you. I can’t.  So don’t you dare think about checking out. I don’t want to hear that again.”

Ironically, Bobby chastised Castiel for lamenting his “uselessness” in 5.21 with much the same speech that Dean gave Bobby (only shorter and a lot less empathetic!). Although Bobby regained the use of his legs at the end of season 5, the brothers had to learn how to survive with Bobby compromised. His frailty had been emphasized throughout the season, symbolically stripping him of his indestructibility and foreshadowing his ultimate downfall.  



Possessed! Bobby

Bobby’s increased screen time in seasons 5 through 7 gave the writers the freedom to experiment with his character. Fans were rewarded with some interesting and dynamic changes. The first expansion of Bobby’s roles occurred immediately at the outset of season 5, when Meg orchestrated Bobby’s possession to get close to Dean.  Although not a new concept in the story line, possession had previously only been a danger to the brothers, who projected a much higher profile in the battle against evil. Bobby’s increased role as both a front line hunter and an indispensable ally to Sam and Dean elevated his exposure to supernatural threats, however.
 image7

5.01 “Sympathy for the Devil” – Bobby possessed for the first time

Season 6 had Bobby “possessed” by a Khan Worm in “…And Then There Were None” (6.16). Then almost humorously, Bobby was cloned by a Leviathan in season 7’s “Slash Fiction." 

image8

7.06 “Slash Fiction” – Jim in dual roles, as Bobby and as a Leviathan  

All of these character changes gave Jim Beaver an opportunity to explore different aspects of Bobby, just as Jensen was able to experiment with talking to himself in a dream state or in the future; or as Possessed!Sam and Soulless!Sam gave Jared a chance to play different versions of Sam. These roles also allowed Jim to shoulder more of the dialog and gave Bobby an expanded presence in story lines.

Romantic Bobby

Although Bobby’s earlier marriage had been mentioned, he had never really been portrayed as a romantic ladies’ man. The later seasons introduced this new side of Bobby, allowing more interaction between him and some interesting female characters. Appropriately, Bobby is first shown cleaning up for his wife, Karen (albeit when she is a zombie!).
 
image8image10

5.15 “Dead Men Don’t Wear Plaid”- Bobby cleaned himself up to impress his wife

In season 6 (6.12 and 6.21), a prior object of his affection, Dr. Eleanor Visyak, plays a pivotal role in the Purgatory myth arc (again proving the importance of Bobby’s character in expanding mythology and story lines with his history). Then an alternate time line tantalized fans by showing Bobby happily married to Ellen. Besides showing a life lost due to Ellen’s sacrifice for hunting, it also gave Samantha Ferris a chance to reprise a great character.

image11

6.17 “My Heart Will Go On” – Bobby is the contented husband, married to Ellen in an alternate time line 

Lastly, in what might have had a flicker of hope for the future, Sherriff Jody Mills surprised Bobby with her offer to clean house and her accidental discovery of a weapon against Leviathans, but he had the last word!

image12

7.06 “Slash Fiction” – Bobby made a surprise move on Sheriff Mills

Bobby as a Leading Man

Given all of the ways that Bobby’s character had been expanded, the logical next step was to give him the leading role in several episodes. “Weekend at Bobby’s” (6.04) was a brilliant culmination of everything that had been building into Bobby’s character in the prior seasons: 

  • Researcher – Providing critical information on a Lamia for Sam and Dean; 
  • Hunter - Killing a demon, summoning a ghost, burying then tracking and killing an Okami,  answering his phone bank for other hunters, and outwitting Crowley for the return of Bobby’s soul;
  • Hunting History - Helping his old hunting partner Rufus;
  • Ladies Man – Being the object of attentions from his neighbor Marcy; 
  • Father Figure - His priceless, epic tirade to Sam and Dean about being the “taken for granted parent” that they ran to for help
6.04

Bobby:   “Sam, Dean, I love you like my own. I do. But sometimes you two are the whiniest, most self-absorbed sons of bitches I ever met. I’m selfish? Me? I do everything for you. Everything! You need some lore scrounged up, you need your asses pulled out of the fire, you need someone to bitch to about each other, you call me and I come through every damn time! And what do I get for it? Jack! With a side of squat!” 

Dean:   “Bobby – 

Bobby:     “Do I sound like I’m done? Now look, I know you’ve got issues. God knows, I know. But I got a news flash for you: you ain’t the center of the universe. Now, it may have slipped your mind, but Crowley owns my soul, and the meter is running, and I will be damned if I am gonna sit around and be damned! So how about you two sack up and help me for once?”

Appropriately, at the end of this episode the leading man is shown trying to enjoy his just desserts. In Bobby’s case, it happens to be peach cobbler instead of pie (who could we be thinking of??), but it will have to do!

image13

6.04 “Weekend at Bobby’s” – The hero tries to eat his reward of Peach Cobbler

In season 7, Bobby was also showcased as the leading man of a story.  The episode, “Death’s Door” (7.10) gave audiences more insight into Bobby’s life than perhaps all of his prior episodes combined. It was a remarkable tribute to the character that had been built, expanded, loved…and lost. 

Killing Bobby 

Okay. The subject can’t be avoided any longer. To the shock and dismay of Supernatural fans everywhere, Bobby was killed off in Season 7. According to published interviews, the idea was to remove all of Sam and Dean’s support systems so that they would be completely and utterly alone facing the Leviathans. One by one, their sanctuaries were taken away from them. The Impala. Their long-standing routines of rock star aliases, road side hotels, and any and all hunting allies, including Bobby. 

Removing Bobby as a safe haven began with the destruction of his home. In a clever play on words, the episode “Hello, Cruel World” (7.02) ended with the vision of Bobby’s house, the only permanent structure the boys had repeatedly retreated to, reduced to smoldering ashes. Besides the impact on the boys’ story, Bobby was now symbolically and literally without a home base. This was perhaps a foreshadowing of his ultimate vulnerability. The next episode showed him briefly retreating to Rufus’ cabin, but he soon began his untethered wanderings to reassemble his library. 7.04 showed him roaming, 7.06 back at the cabin, 7.09 travelling with the boys and staying in an abandoned house to hide from Leviathans. Then in the tradition of so many before him, Bobby was killed by the supernatural epitome of evil that he was hunting. It was shocking. It was painful. Fandom cried along with Sam and Dean. How could Bobby be gone? 

Since this aspect of Bobby’s story upset almost everyone in the Supernatural family, his death didn’t last long.  It might have been in the plan all along, or it might have been sparked by the universal outrage at the lost of a beloved character, but it led to the last aspect of Bobby’s character that was introduced. It wasn’t without precedent, but still it was a little surprising….

Lazarus!Bobby (Bobby as a Ghost)

Although Bobby almost died hunting several times, in 5.22 “Swan Song”, Bobby joined the elite ranks of characters who were thoroughly killed dead then brought back to life.  Without thinking about this too long, up to this point Sam and Dean were the only humans who could previously claim the honor of having their bodies revived. Mary and John also had their spirits revived once their corporeal bodies had died, so there was definitely precedent for Bobby’s return to the story. After Bobby was resurrected the first time, though, his revivals became almost as common as Sam or Dean’s! 

image14

5.22 “Swan Song” – The first time Bobby is resurrected by Castiel. 

In “And Then There Were None” (6.16) Bobby presumably died by electrocution of the Khan Worm and is resuscitated by Sam and Dean. In “Death’s Door” (7.10) Bobby’s body dies but his spirit starts to attach itself to the brothers almost immediately.  Then in “Party On, Garth” (7.18) Bobby’s ghost finally becomes visible and begins a journey of its own.

image15

7.19 “Of Grave Importance” – Bobby experiencing the perils of being a ghost 

Through the next few episodes, Bobby’s ghost becomes vengeful, however, until finally in the climax to season 7, Sam and Dean released Bobby’s spirit from this world. 

So that would be the end of Bobby’s story in anybody’s sane expectation of a plot line. Then, in what has to be a reflection of Bobby’s stature as a truly beloved leading character of the series, his soul accomplished something that had only been done previously by Sam, Dean and John – his body/spirit/soul is rescued from Hell. In his only appearance in season 8, Bobby is found in Hell by Sam in “Taxi Driver” (8.19). 

image16

8.19 “Taxi Driver” – the last shot of Bobby, as his soul is being absorbed for transport to Heaven

Bobby is rescued, brought back to Earth and his soul is released to Heaven. 

image17

8.19  “Taxi Driver” – Bobby’s soul is put to rest in Heaven…or is it?

So Bobby’s journey from a single episode in season 1 to a resurrected character that survived seven years made what appeared to be its final transition. Is it reasonable to assume that this, finally, is the end of Bobby’s storyline?  Will the fans let him go?  Will Sam and Dean? Will the writers? John’s spirit went to Heaven and hasn’t been heard from since, but then again, John wasn’t in 55 episodes before his demise. The only other supporting character that has had that level of impact on the show is Castiel, who ironically, also has been in exactly 55 episodes. As Jim Beaver has said so often, “This is Supernatural.  Anything is possible.” One can only hope…

********************

I hope you have enjoyed this photographic journey through the character of Bobby Singer. We started with the first picture of Bobby in the series and we ended with the last picture (so far!!). Please share any favorite moments that I might have missed.  Are there special shots of Bobby that weren’t included in the photos? Are there aspects of his character that you perceived that I didn’t mention?  I might do a follow-up article on “Things I Have Learned from Bobby”, but I think I’ll give Bobby a rest for a while. What are your thoughts? I promised that the article would be spoiler free, but I make no promises about the comments, so proceed at your own risk!

This series of articles would not have been possible without the wonderful information found on:

www.homeofthenutty.com

www.supernaturalwiki.com

www.Wikipedia.org

www.imdb.com

Comments  

KELLY
# KELLY 2013-09-20 19:31
It was a lovely analysis. I quite like the geek statistic stuff personally. I loved Death's Door despite it being horribly sad. I did think they knew they were bringing him back as a ghost, but I don't think it was done extremely well.
Kelebek
# Kelebek 2013-09-20 23:25
Thanks, Nightsky, for this review. I really enjoy looking back at all seasons of SPN through other people's perspectives. I, like the rest of the fans, couldn't believe that they'd killed Bobby.....it was great to see him back even if it was as a ghost! :-)
Maybe it's because I just finished watching 'the devil you know', that I have this one Bobby line in my head (said to Crowley):
"Well, then get the hell off my property before I blast you so full of rock salt, you crap margaritas."
It's not a photographic moment of Bobby per se, but I can't help but laugh every time I think about it.
leah unlogged
# leah unlogged 2013-09-21 11:58
This was a very fitting tribute to Bobby. I enjoyed all three parts. I will always miss him being a part of Sam and Dean's daily lives. I do admit to having mixed feelings about them bringing him back repeatedly. The farewell in Death's Door was sad and lovely. As much as I love Bobby/Jim I sorta wish they had left it at that. But I admit to looking forward to it when they say he's returning! Conflicted much?
novi
# novi 2013-09-21 12:29
Too good an actor to lose him, too adorable a character, Bobby (and Jim) really became an integral part of the show so whenever they bring him back I will be greeting him with huge Welcome as I think everybody on set does.
nightsky
# nightsky 2013-09-21 17:20
Kelly, Thank you for the feedback about the data tables! I created those as I was writing Part 1 and used them continuously while researching the rest of the story, so they were invaluable to me. I just wasn't sure if anyone else would find them interesting. I'm glad you liked them!
nightsky
# nightsky 2013-09-21 17:26
Kelebek, I love that line too! The writers gave Bobby really witty quips. I think that is part of his charm. Actually, the next part of this series of articles will be all the wise things he said to the brothers. I have been writing them down as I remember them or see them on reruns, but I am still missing so many!
nightsky
# nightsky 2013-09-21 17:46
Leah and Novi, I admit I am on the side of looking forward to having Bobby back. Jim commented that it was an interesting, new angle, so I am open to seeing what the writers have cooked up. It doesn't bother me that they keep bringing Bobby back. I like the character and the actor, and I think he is a healthy addition to the brothers' lives. I like that he isn't afraid to yell at them, support them, challenge them, etc. Frankly, for all the reasons stated in the article, I think the character has become so valuable to telling the story that his presence makes a few things easier for the writers (plot and character exposition, for example) and enriches the story. As much as I like Charlie and Kevin as supporting characters, neither one can compete with the 7 year history we have with Bobby. He is a non-controversi al, liked, easy character to write; the actor is available and easy to work with and has his own following that adds viewers to the show. Really, it's all up-side to use him.