Supernatural Season Seven: Hits and Misses – A Second Look
It’s been a few years now since I began the "Hits and Misses" reflections pieces. They’re always a fun way to look back at the last ten years of adventures, emotional moments and character arcs of our favourite brothers. The season seven list holds a unique distinction since in fact it was during the mid-season finale of season seven that I first did a "Hits and Misses" article, looking at what the season in progress had been successful at so far, what it had utterly struck out on and where it may have possibilities for course-correcting in the second half of season seven.
So here we are years later, and the opportunity for a full "Hits and Misses" reflection cannot be ignored. For those interested, here is the link to the original piece:
Supernatural Hits and Misses of Season Seven. In that article, I reflected on how well the show fulfilled my hopes back in 2012. In this Second Look, I'll reflect on what I still consider a hit or miss and what needs to be added to the original list having seen how the season finally concluded.
(As always, no particular order to these items)
Hit: Broment – Stone One

This may have not been resolved very well and it may have become incredibly gimmicky throughout the season, with the visual of Sam doing the now infamous “palm press” to ward off Lucifer hallucinations and the like. With that said, when Dean initially pulled Sam back from the edge and the two connected after the “wall” was shattered was still a strong moment. This is the kind of connection we like to see between these two – and it’s this same connection that years later would have Sam break through the MoC's hold over his brother to stop him from killing Sam. So, regardless of how the storyline would later play out, in the beginning it was a great moment and a hit.
Miss: Benching Baby

This was on my original list and really needs little explanation. What I will say is that the Impala did have some badassery and style in her comeback at the end of the season when she finally returned, so some redemption I suppose.
Hit: Dopplegangers

As above, this was on the original list and it remains a hit. It’s always fun to watch Jared and Jensen play alternate versions of Sam and Dean, especially as bad guys – and the Leviathan interpretations were as witty and clever as always. In addition, the plot revealed the borax weakness – something we’d been needing for a long while. It was a good episode overall.
Miss: Amy, Amy, Amy

Also an original list feature and one that’s been discussed to death so let’s not address it in depth again. It’s a miss because it became a redundancy of drawn out, unneeded tension and contrived, improperly addressed issues that were so unneeded it was incredible. If there was ever a flashing arrow in season seven that said “FAILED PLOT DEVICE”, it pointed straight at the Amy story, no question.
Hit: Storming Sucracorp

This was fun, dramatic and strategic. One advantage of big, corporate bad guys – you need a military maneuver style plan and a whole different way to go about getting to the head of the snake.
Miss: Dean the Drunkard

This also comes from the original list and is apropos after season ten in many ways. Season seven failed at showing Dean struggle with his may-or-may-not-exist issues, largely because it seemed they just couldn’t commit to the plot point or the motivations. Season ten demonstrated much better the descent into and struggle against internal demons and the reactions of those around him. Yes, wholly different story elements – but a smoother way to go, in my opinion. And regardless of how you may feel about season ten, season seven missed on this drinking Dean, fully and completely.
Hit: The Fabulous Mind of Bobby Singer

Don’t need to say much here: terribly sad circumstances warranted an incredible ride. It was visually outstanding and emotionally overwhelming at every step: and that’s why it’s made the list twice!
Miss: Opportinities

Season seven brought incredible new, powerful villains of the likes we’d never seen before. Leviathan became a common enemy to demons and humans alike and a threat to so many other supernatural beings in existence. We of course saw the demon storyline play out and a tease of the vampires too; but what about everybody else? Witches, werecreatures, psychics, demigods – where was everybody? It seems more people (creatures) might have been interested in attempting to stop the Leviathan or even seeking out the Winchesters based on their reputations to offer a truce, solution, anything...even attempting something within their own clans. Yet – nothing. Missed chance for great drama somewhere in there.
Hit: Hello Charlie!

As we well know by now, Charlie Bradbury was an excellent, semi-regular addition to the
Supernatural family. She was clever, nerdy in the best way, brave and a female character with no romantic overtones whatsoever who just enhanced our characters' lives even as she grew from uncertain to kickass. From her opening montage, it was clear this red-head hacker was going to bring fun and wit to the Winchesters, and she certainly didn’t disappoint.
Miss: Goodbye Bobby

Actually, I’m a little mixed on this one. Bobby’s death was a tribute well done. And the grieving of the brothers was, for the most part displayed in very real ways. Ultimately, even the recognition on Ghost-Bobby’s part of what he was becoming and his decision to go, made on his own, was alright. It’s the fact that there was a ghost who had a decision to make in the first place that leaves me mixed. Of course, keeping Bobby around as often as possible is wonderful, but in some ways, I can’t help but wonder if it wouldn’t have been better to make the first goodbye scene, the final goodbye on that front. So, really, this isn’t a miss per se, but a wonder. Season seven had some of those moments that teetered on the edge of incredible but were pushed too far and ended up in overdone and/or lackluster territory – maybe to ghost storyline hovered nearby.
So there we have it, part 1 in retrospect. Do you agree with my choices? Stay tuned for part 2 - coming soon!
Comments
The Amy line, I am in agreement. Makes me wonder if it was a filler of sorts. I don't know.
Overall this is a good piece and I'm glad to have read it. I look forward to part 2.
Regardless, season 7 did actually have some really great episodes in there, such as: "Death's Door," "The Mentalists," "Time After Time," "The Born-Again Identity," "Of Great Importance," and "The Girl With the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo." Each of these episodes were fabulous. I will also add that Dick Roman was a great "big bad," and Lucifer's return was handled really well.
Two controversial aspects of the season that I think worked quite well were (1) Bobby's death and (2) the absence of Baby. Both were sad, but I think they worked well in the context of the story being told.
Bobby's character was given a great send-off, which cemented his place in the story as THE MOST IMPORTANT recurring character of Supernatural--m ore important than even John, Castiel and/or Crawley. Also, unlike Castiel, Bobby served his purpose in the story (as a mentor and father figure), but then was given a fitting exit. Contrast this to Castiel, who is overused and essentially has no real purpose in the story other than to keep a certain fan base satisfied.
Also, the absence of the Impala was handled well. We missed baby during the season, but were delighted to see her triumphant return in the season finale. It was really one great pay-off the way Sam & Dean orchestrated a direct attack on Dick Roman. Awesome!!
What really killed season 7 was the leviathans as villains. They were a very badly conceived concept. Rather than being terrifying, they were comical. Also, the fact that they could be killed by simple cleaning detergent just seemed too ludicrous to be believed.
There were also a string of badly written episodes (mostly towards the beginning), plus the "cliffhanger" type format the writers were experimenting with just didn't work. Also, the ultimate resolution of the season just seemed too arbitrary.
Overall Grade: B-
About Baby being put up... that probably shouldn't be counted as a miss, because the writers didn't have a choice. Money was finally granted to overhaul one of the main 'Baby's, souping up her engine and giving her an overhaul in a restoration project that was pretty expensive and time consuming. Now they can actually film her with her own engine sounds! Anyway, taking Baby out the game was a necessity and can't really be put down as a fail in the writing.
Loved "stone number one," hated the hand squeeze cure all and the Lucifer quick fix, but loved all the hallucinations while they lasted. Hated depressed, drinking Dean; no one wants to watch a pity party and I really don't feel like self-pity is a Dean Winchester character trait anyway, so not only was he morose and unpleasant, but I never felt like it was very true to his character anyway.
The only thing that was a miss about the Amy thing for me was that the show ultimately put Sam in the wrong for being angry at Dean about killing her. That really P'd me off. It's been discussed to DEATH around here, so I'm not going to dredge it up, but suffice to say that it was one of my absolute LEAST favorite moments in all of season 7 and possibly the series. The fact that they repeated that same idea with the possession (somehow that also became Sam's fault) makes it particularly bitter for me. Still that episode does not rank as low as some others.
However, hind sight is a funny thing. When season seven aired, I was a bit 'meh' about it. There were some very good eps and some not so good ones, and the year long big bad didn't work out very well, but compared to the Carver years season seven is looking better and better all the time. I liked it better than 8, 9 or 10 when taken as a whole. When I look at my list of all time worst Supernatural episodes ever none of them come from season 7. They are, in no particular order - Bloodlines (9), Taxi Driver(8), Bad Boys (9), Paint it Black (10), Mannequin II: The Reckoning (6), Man's Best Friends with Benefits (8). Most of them are from seasons 8, 9, and 10, three of them are by Eugenie and Brad. By comparison, season 7 is looking pretty good.
In MY opinion, Carver's tenure has been the worst period of the show and has produced some of the worst episodes of SPN like Bad Boys, that horrible nun episode from this season, that musical episode, the boring S10 premiere, that spinoff episode, any and all episodes containing FBs of Amelia or Amelia in person. I may have disliked the way SG handled Sam's hallucinations after HCW and the way the Amy contrived conflict was resolved and everything about the Leviathans as the BBs, but in hindsight, those plots . . . S7, in general, was much better than any of the seasons that succeeded it. Like you, most of the episodes I greatly dislike are in seasons 8, 9, and 10. Heck, I can barely remember what happened in many of the S8-10 episodes, and trying to remember the names of the episodes is a waste of time for me. Lately, people will reference an episode, and I will have no idea what the episode is about b/c this season was so horrible, boring, and uneventful to me. It's a shame. S7 is far superior to any Carver season IMO.
Yes, I loved Bobby and was sad to see him go, but his departure was so well done. And in some ways he had become a kind of crutch to the boys. My favorite part of SPN is watching the brothers work together as a team to fight evil, and I could see why Sera wanted to get back to that basic premise of the show- the boys against the world. I also had no problem with ghost Bobby, any more than I had a problem with ghost John, Mary, Jess, etc. I originally thought that Sam should have suffered much worse repercussions from the broken wall than the Lucifer hallucinations, but I can see why the show went the route it did. There couldn't be too quick a fix, but they needed Sam to be functional enough to hunt with Dean. And I absolutely loved "stone cold number one." I also agree that Dean's drinking was entirely to be expected, and I did not find Dean to be as morose as others found him. At least he retained his essential Dean qualities, like his protectiveness of Sammy and some semblance of a sense of humor. S7 Dean was an absolute picnic compared to S9-10 Dean, who truly was mired in self-pity to the exclusion of almost everything else. He seemed very OOC for most of those seasons and I really missed old Dean. Above all else, I liked S7 because for almost the entirety of the season the brothers were on the same page, looking out for and caring about each other, except for the brief Amy rift. There was almost no contrived, unpleasant, OOC drama between them.
I also found your insights into the mental health aspects of the brothers in S7 to be very interesting, and much-appreciate d.
Charlie. I loved Charlie from the moment we met her and that never changed. I will never forgive Carver and Singer for what they did to her.
Frank (I still refuse to believe he is dead) was fabulous. I absolutely loved him. His snark was even snarkier than Dean's.
Kevin the teenage prophet. His introduction to the Supernatural was perfect. He was a great addition to the show.
There really were some fun episodes in S7.
However it was a season in disarray unfortunately. Maybe because SG was on her way out and she didn't really get to realize her vision (whatever that might have been). Hard to say why it didn't work as well as S6.
I agree benching the Impala was a mistake. I would have thought restorations could have taken place during hiatus.
Killing Bobby was a huge mistake since he was immediately replaced with Frank. Bringing him back as a ghost was just ridiculous.
Amy as a standalone episode would have been fine but to use her as a rift between the brothers was very poorly executed, pointless and quickly forgotten.
Killing Castiel and not making him the big bad of the season was a huge miss. His character was set up beautifully to be the next adversary for the brothers. Having said that he should have remained dead. No one seems to know what to do with Castiel even now (rabid dog? Really). He really hasn't had much of a storyline since S4.
And yes drunk depressed Dean was depressing. Dean had fun and badass (Time after Time) moments but for the most part he was a drag.
Dropping Sam's hell story was also a miss. But I think one that maybe wasn't supposed to play out the way it did. Could be wrong but it just felt like it was dropped pretty quickly and resolved in an unsatisfactory way just to bring back a fan favorite.
S7 was my second full season of live watching. I was still madly in love with the show and couldn't wait for each new episode. I wasn't really disappointed just confused by the story direction.
Still love the show (even S8, 9 and 10) and still can't wait for each new episode.
I had no problem w/them benching the Impala, but the idea that Dean was taking that dirty, bloody coat and moving it from car to car was just silly. I also hated the doppleganger aspect b/c the impact of those actions weren't fully realized. Sam and Dean should still be well-known serial murderers who can't just walk the streets like normal ppl.
But about the restoration project on baby, Jim Michaels mentioned it several times. I guess it took a lot longer than expected and was pretty costly even for a TV show with money behind it to move things along. My understanding is that they rebuilt the engine. They have been overdubbing Baby's engine sounds for years. Baby's engine was actually an old Mustang engine inserted into the episode in post production. Now they can actually film her using her own engine and she sounds so bad ass!
If you listen closely to baby in the first 6 seasons and baby now, she does in fact sound a bit different, it's not too noticeable, but it's there.
There are six impala's total, but this is the one they call "hero" on the set because she's a bad ass and has all the bells and whistles. Others are the smashed one from season 1 and the one that is on the back of a truck for interior driving scenes. If you listen to her engine you can hear that it's not quite the same as the sounds from earlier seasons, but still awesome.
[video]https:// www.youtube.com /watch?v=q1ER1f j0Pw8[/video]
That car must be so much more fun to drive now after all that work. I distinctly remember Jensen saying at a Con a few years back before the work was done that the car "handles like a shopping cart." I'll bet that's not true now.
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBALmWz5Kzg[/video]
Quote: Hopefully he managed to get it in his contract!
Believe me, I am NO car person, I am just repeating what I learned from a cute video with Jeff Budnick who's in charge of the Impalas on the show. According to him, they replaced the engine entirely with a 500 HP high performance engine (Chevrolet engine) an entirely new suspension kit, something about the "rear end" I have no idea what he was talking about, all new disc brakes on all four wheels. She was detailed as well and it's my understanding that the four door hard top is rather rare. I think all that took some time. Again, I know absolutely nothing about cars and haven't a clue as to how much time is realistic for something like this, but there are many accounts out there of people spending years getting their Impala's restored.
For season eleven I am hopeful. For Sam and rest. Can't wait. If I survived s7 I will survive the rest.