Best Brotherly Bonding Scene
Winner (by a massive landslide)
Dean talking Sam through his psychotic episode in the warehouse, aka the "stone number one" scene - "Hello, Cruel World"
The ending scene in "Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie"
I didn't think this category would be much of a contest, especially when only 3 scenes were nominated. I did think later that maybe I should have added the little talk in the beginning of "The Born Again Identity" but it didn't matter. There was clearly one big winner this year. In a season devoid of many brotherly moments, the "stone number one" speech stands up to all the classic brotherly scenes of years past, let alone the paltry number in season seven.
Still, 22% of you still liked the end of "Plucky Pennywhistle's" better. Given the fact it involved laughs and smiles, something that anymore requires you to rub your eyes hard to make sure you aren't seeing things, it was a rare moment in brotherhood.