Best Season Seven Guest Star
Winner (by a landslide)
Mark Pellegrino - Lucifer
Julian Richings - Death
Not Far Behind Runner Up Status
Kim Rhodes - Sheriff Jody Mills
Felicia Day - Charlie
This result shocked me. There were so many great guest stars, so many nominees to chose from, it was impossible for me to even get them down to a list of seven. As often as I read comments from people saying how impossible it was to choose, the winner, Lucifer, played by Mark Pellegrino, ended up getting almost twice as many votes as the runner up, Death. The real race was for second place, where Julian Richings eeked out a win over Kim Rhodes and Felicia Day. The rest were left far behind.
I recently commented on Twitter that Lucifer was far more creepy than the Leviathan, so I say if you had to choose someone, that was a great choice.