Page 5 of 5â€œLike the X-Men?â€ Exact like the X-Men Dean says. The guy theyâ€™re taking him too is even in a wheelchair. Oh Bobby! Yep, still sad for him. â€œYouâ€™ll be a hero. Youâ€™ll save lives, youâ€™ll get the girl. Sound like fun, right?â€ Jesse is smiling, loving all this talk. So who here thought this was going to work? The two of you can put your hands down now. Dean goes flying against the wall. Julia walks in and then throws Sam there too. Oh come on, not the TK toss again. Forget the fact that itâ€™s already been done to Dean too many times, Sam makes no sense. How can be immune to the bright ray of doom from Samhain and Lilith but can be tossed by a lower level demon? Iâ€™m okay if Samâ€™s powers are gone, but after Alastair couldnâ€™t fling him last season, I figured we were done with that.
Julia tells â€œdreamboatâ€ aka Sam, that she canâ€™t hurt him, orders. As for Dean, itâ€™s encouraged. She tosses him against the other wall in full force, and then back again. Jesse shouts out to leave him alone. Julia looks at him and tells him heâ€™s beautiful (which he is) and he has his fatherâ€™s eyes. She tells him sheâ€™s his mother. Jesse says she isnâ€™t because he can tell thereâ€™s something inside her. â€œYouâ€™re half human, and youâ€™re half one of us.â€ Dean speaks out she means demons and Julia pulls out her fist and forces Dean to shut up quick. Aw man, why canâ€™t I have that power for my kids? Life isnâ€™t fair.
She goes on telling Jesse that those people he calls his parent lied to him. Heâ€™s not theirs. Jesse says they love him but she asks is that why they leave him alone all day. She actually does have a point there. She gets mean though, pointing out he was lied to when they said the tooth fairy was real and his toys could hurt him. â€œThey love you so much they made your whole life a lie. Look into your heart Jesse. Youâ€™ve always known you werenâ€™t theirs, youâ€™ve always known you were different.â€ Everyone has lied to him. Sam and Dean are not FBI agents and heâ€™s not a superhero. Man, this is really harsh stuff for an 11 year old.
Jesse wants to know what he is. â€œYouâ€™re powerful. You can have anything you want, you can do anything you want.â€ Dean tells him not to listen to her, so Julia demon twists her fist more to get him to shut up. She goes on about how everyone has been treating him like a kid and not telling him the truth. She asks doesnâ€™t that make him angry, so he clenches his fists, the lights flicker and flames start shooting out of the fireplace. Yep, not a kid to get mad. She promises him a world with no lies. He can come with her and start over.
Now it's Sam's turn to try and get through to Jesse by promising to tell him the truth, but Julia demon goes for the fist twist on him. Jesse actually wants to hear what Sam has to say and uses his power to get Sam off the wall. Julia demon is impressed, for the kid's more powerful than she thought. Sam apologizes for lying and tells Jesse who they are and that they hunt monsters. â€œExcept when you are the monster, huh Sammy?â€ Boy, both angels and demons are never going to let him live that down, are they? Hunters too. And Dean. And every Sam hating fan out there (sorry, I couldnâ€™t resist). Sam tells Jesse that is his mother, but the thing inside her is a demon. Julia tells Jesse that Sam has done nothing but lie to him. â€œPunish him!â€ Youâ€™re telling the Anti-Christ what to do? On thatâ€™s so going to backfire lady.
Jesse tells her to sit down and shut up, then with his mind throws her into a nearby chair and forces her mouth shut. Sam goes on, all tender and sympathetic. â€œThere's kind of a war between angels and demons and youâ€™re a part of it.â€ Iâ€™ll say! Sam tells him he can go with her if he wants, he canâ€™t stop him, but if he does, millions of people will die. Jesse wants to know if heâ€™s really half demon. â€œYes. But youâ€™re half human too. You can do the right thing. Youâ€™ve got choices Jesse, but if you make the wrong ones itâ€™ll haunt you for the rest of your life.â€ Oh Sam, again with the personal experience appeal? Jesse wants to know why heâ€™s telling him this. "Because I have to believe someone can make the right choice, even if I couldnâ€™t." It's as if Jesse understands everything Sam's saying. I'm not sure if he trusts Sam instinctively because they both have demon power or because he fell for the puppy dog eyes, but Jesse expels the demon from Julia. Dean comes off the wall. Dean asks how he did that and Jesse says he just did. Dean calls him awesome.
The tough part of Sam and Dean's job is yet to come. They have to tell this boy the truth. Jesse asks if Julia is going to be alright. Eventually. Sorry kid, but she hasnâ€™t been alright for a long time. This isnâ€™t going to help. You see, I told you this gets dark fast. Dean picks up the Castiel doll off the floor. He tells Jesse he's a buddy of his and if thereâ€™s anyway he can turn him back. Jesse is still mad that Cas tried to kill him. Dean defends Cas. â€œRight. Heâ€™s a good guy. He was just confused. He realizes Jesse isn't budging for now and puts Cas on the mantle, resolving to talk about it later.
Jesse asks what now? Dean looks at Sam, who shrugs. Dean takes the lead. He wants to take him someplace safe, get him trained up. â€œYouâ€™d be handy in a fight kid.â€ Sam comes over, because he can see that Dean isnâ€™t convincing him. â€œJesse, youâ€™re powerful. More powerful than pretty much anything weâ€™ve ever seen. That makes you-â€ â€œA freak?â€ Jesse says. You see, he does get Sam! â€œTo some people maybe, but not to us. Weâ€™re freaks ourselves.â€ Two really hot freaks.
Jesse asks if he can stay there. Dean says no. The demons know where he is and more will be coming. He doesnâ€™t want to go without his mom and dad. Sam tells him family is important, and heâ€™ll support him if he wants them to go, but itâ€™ll be dangerous for them too. Jesse doesnâ€™t understand. Dean handles this one and Iâ€™m adoring the Sam and Dean tag teaming on this one. â€œOur dad, he would takes us wherever he went.â€ Jesse asks where he is now. â€œDead,â€ Sam says without hesitation. â€œA demon killed him.â€ Back to Dean. â€œJesse, once youâ€™re in this fight, youâ€™re in it until the end. Win or lose.â€ Come on guys, heâ€™s 11! This is just too much. Truth is good but laying it all out like this? I guess they have no choice.
Jesse wants to know what he should do. Sam admits they canâ€™t tell him, itâ€™s his choice. Oh, all three of these guys are killing me here! Wow, how sad that this boy has to go through this, and that Sam and Dean have to deliver the news. Jesse asks if he can see his parents, he needs to say goodbye. Dean says sure. The poor little kid, who right now is crushing my heart into wittle pieces, takes the long walk up the stairs, the melancholy score playing in the background. He stares at his sleeping parents, and then goes to his room. He drops down onto his bed, the weight of the world on his shoulders. Man this kid is a great actor. He stares at the bright blue poster of Australia on the wall.
Now Sam is playing with the Castiel doll. It's infectious! Dean realizes Jesse's been up there a long time and goes upstairs to check it out. They go in his room and he's gone. Hey, if I could do it, I'd zap myself to Australia in a heartbeat. Castiel, now in full sized live action hero, announces Jesse is gone and doesnâ€™t know where he is. He put back the people hurt in the town back to normal, the ones alive anyway. Oh, so toothless gets his teeth back but will always have memories of that trauma to haunt him? I don't think his little girl is going to mention losing teeth anymore. Sam reads the goodbye note, yep, he's left so his parents can be safe. Great going guys. You lost the Anti-Christ! That's going to end well.
Sam and Dean are in the Impala and they're both pretty glum. Dean wonders if the kid is going to be okay, Sam hopes so. Thatâ€™s Winchester speak for theyâ€™re both really scared for the kid. Dean states the obvious, by telling that kid the truth they've destroyed his life. â€œWe didnâ€™t have a choice Dean.â€ Yeah, Samâ€™s right there. Itâ€™s sad, but heâ€™s right. â€œYou know, Iâ€™m starting to get why parents lie to their kids. You want them believe the worst thing out there is mixing pop rocks and coke.â€ He wishes their dad lied to them. Sam, who's quietly brooding, can only say "me too." End credits. Wow, that was a downer.