Article Index



Welcome to Summer Hellatus 2012! Just like we have the last few summers, we've got some great “Supernatural” related activities/articles planned to help us get through this longer than ever Hellatus. Today, we kick off this special time with a traditional audience participation activity - rank the “Supernatural” episodes in five minutes. 
Now try not to panic like Sam Winchester spotting some clowns.  The rules are simple. Below is a list of all the “Supernatural” season seven episodes. It’s your job to rank them from best to worst in your opinion in five minutes. There’s no second guessing – the idea is to capture your gut reaction.  So make your list and then share your answers, for we’re all about sharing here. You don’t have to have your list typed in five minutes, just your order jotted down. 
Be sure to check out page two, which are my rankings. I’ll admit with an extra episode I didn’t rank these as quickly as I did last year. I still made it within five minutes though.  However, I am an expert with plenty of “Supernatural” encyclopedic knowledge, so if it takes you a little more than five minutes, no one has to know. Just keep it between you and the cat. No second guessing though and taking time to rearrange. That would be cheating and Fluffy knows you're better than that. 
Okay, ready?  Without further adieu here are the episodes. Good luck!

Meet The New Boss
Hello, Cruel World
The Girl Next Door
Defending Your Life
Shut Up Dr. Phil
Slash Fiction
The Mentalists
Season 7: Time For A Wedding
How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
Death’s Door
Adventures in Babysitting
Time After Time
The Slice Girls
Plucky Pennywhistle’s Magical Menagerie
Repo Man
Out With The Old
The Born-Again Identity
Party On, Garth
Of Grave Importance
The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
Reading Is Fundamental
There Will Be Blood
Survival of The Fittest
 



Comments  

Nikki2
# Nikki2 2012-05-23 16:29
Meet The New Boss
Hello, Cruel World
Death’s Door
Time After Time
Slash Fiction
The Born-Again Identity
Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
Repo Man
Reading Is Fundamental
Survival of The Fittest
The Slice Girls
How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
Of Grave Importance
The Mentalists
Out With The Old
The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
Defending Your Life
There Will Be Blood
Shut Up Dr. Phil
The Girl Next Door
Adventures in Babysitting
Party On, Garth
Season 7: Time For A Wedding
Thisoldbag58
# Thisoldbag58 2012-05-23 16:38
Meet the new boss
Hello cruel world
Girl next door
Reading is fundamental
There will be blood
Survival of the fittest
Plucky penny whistles
Time after time
Born again identity
Out with the old
Party on Garth
Slash fiction
Time for a wedding
How to win friends...
Mentalists
Adventures in babysitting
Shut up Dr Phil
Defending your life
Slice girls
Girl w dungeons...
Grave importance
Deaths door
Repo man
Gerry
# Gerry 2012-05-23 16:58
Hello cruel world
Deaths door
Reading Is Fundamental
Born again identity
Slash fiction
How to win friends...
Time after time
Repo man
Mentalists
Survival of the fittest
Meet the new boss
Slice girls
Girl next door
Grave importance
Adventures in babysitting
Party on Garth
Out with the old
Defending your life
Plucky penny whistles
Girl w dungeons...
Shut up Dr Phil
There will be blood
Time for a wedding
EireneS
# EireneS 2012-05-23 17:25
Death's Door
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
Survival of the Fittest
How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
Repo Man
Time After Time
Reading is Fundamental
The Girl with the Dungeon and Dragon Tattoo
There Will Be Blood
Meet The New Boss
Hello Cruel World
The Mentalists
Slash Fiction
Out With The Old
The Born Again Identity
Of Grave Importance
Party On Garth
The Slice Girls
Adventures in Babysitting
Season 7-Time For a Wedding
The Girl Next Door
Defending Your Life
Shut Up Dr Phil
Lena
# Lena 2012-05-23 17:30
Adventures in baby.....
Shut up Dr....
Party on Garth
The Girl with the Dungeons......
The girt next door
Defending your life
Of grave importance
Reading is fundamental
Repo man
The slice girls
The mentalist
Time for a wedding
Time after time
Out with the old
Slash fiction
Plucky ......
There will be blood
Survival of.......
The Born again.......
Hello, cruel......
Death's door
How to win friends.......
Meet the new boss

The best ep is last and de worst ep first. Sorry : )
Melanie
# Melanie 2012-05-23 17:46
1 Hello, Cruel World

2 The Born-Again Identity

3 Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

4 Slash Fiction

5 Repo Man

6 Out with the Old

7 Meet the New Boss

8 The Girl With the Dungeons & Dragon Tattoos

9 Shut Up, Dr. Phil

10 Adventures in Babysitting

11 The Mentalists

12 Time After Time

13 Reading Is Fundamental

14 There Will Be Blood

15 Survival of the Fittest

16 Of Grave Importance

17 The Slice Girls

18 Defending your life

19 Girl Next Door

20 Party On Garth

21 How to win friends and influence monsters

22 Death’s Door

23 Season 7 Time for a Wedding


I'm ranking these based on my persoanl enjoyment of the episodes. Not on 'quality' per se. Yes, Death's Door was an exceptionally well done episode. But I didn't like it.
Mickey
# Mickey 2012-05-23 18:42
Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie

Slash Fiction

Death’s Door

The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo

Time After Time

Meet The New Boss

Hello, Cruel World

Survival of The Fittest

Repo Man

The Mentalists

Season 7: Time For A Wedding

Party On, Garth

The Born-Again Identity

Shut Up Dr. Phil

How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters

Of Grave Importance

Reading Is Fundamental

There Will Be Blood

Out With the Old

The Girl Next Door

Defending Your Life

The Slice Girls

Adventures in Babysitting

Six minutes! Dammit, I was doing good time, then I only came out to 22 and couldn't figure out which one I was missing.
Gwen
# Gwen 2012-05-23 18:58
1. Hello, Cruel World
2. Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
3. Meet The New Boss
4. Repo Man
5. Death’s Door
6. The Born-Again Identity (awesome Limp!Sam, would have been near very top if there'd been more brotherly moments.)
7. Out With The Old
8. Slash Fiction
9. The Girl Next Door
10.Time After Time
11. How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
12. Season 7: Time For A Wedding
13. The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
14. There Will Be Blood
15. Of Grave Importance
16. Party On, Garth

I couldn't separate these episodes below. They are all, equally, my least favourites.

Defending Your Life
Shut Up Dr. Phil
The Mentalists
Adventures in Babysitting
Reading Is Fundamental
Survival of The Fittest
The Slice Girls
Michelle Kinseth
# Michelle Kinseth 2012-05-23 18:58
Hello, Cruel World
The Mentalists
How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
Death’s Door
Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
Meet The New Boss
Slash Fiction
Repo Man
Out With The Old
Reading Is Fundamental
There Will Be Blood
Survival of The Fittest
Of Grave Importance
Time After Time
The Slice Girls
The Born-Again Identity
Party On, Garth
Adventures in Babysitting
Defending Your Life
The Girl Next Door
Shut Up Dr. Phil
Season 7: Time For A Wedding

The middle of the list is decidedly the hardest to rank! Average episodes are all just...average.
magichappening
# magichappening 2012-05-23 19:01
Well it took me eight minutes (!), but here is my first pass (which almost certainly will change...):
1. The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
2. Death’s Door
3. Slash Fiction
4. Adventures in Babysitting
5. There Will Be Blood
6. Time After Time
7. Hello, Cruel World
8. The Girl Next Door
9. Survival of The Fittest
10. The Slice Girls
11. Reading Is Fundamental
12. Meet The New Boss
13. Out With The Old
14. The Mentalists
15. Season 7: Time For A Wedding
16. How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
17. Repo Man
18. Of Grave Importance
19. The Born-Again Identity
20. Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
21. Defending Your Life
22. Party On, Garth
23. Shut Up Dr. Phil

Fascinating as always to see the similarities and differences in everyone's lists :-)
Ginger
# Ginger 2012-05-23 19:03
Repo Man
Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
Time After Time
Slash Fiction
Survival of The Fittest
Meet The New Boss
Hello, Cruel World
Death's Door (Because Rufus was seen again)
How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters (Despite that
awful Yoda Bobby scene)
The Slice Girls
Out With The Old
Reading Is Fundamental
The Mentalists
Of Grave Importance
There Will Be Blood
The Born-Again Identity
Defending Your Life
Shut Up Dr. Phil
Party On, Garth
The Girl Next Door (only because I liked Dean's cold kill)
Adventures in Babysitting
The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
Season 7: Time For A Wedding

In looking to rate all the episodes, it's sad that there are two that I loved and two others that I liked a lot. Then there's two that I didn't care for at all, and three that I hated. The rest can be lumped in as okay and I was entertained for the hour.

I placed Repo Man as my top pick because (1) when I think about the season as a whole, this is the one that always stands out to me. We've had too few instances of showing the Winchesters (particularly Dean) as dangerous people (Ghostfacers comes to mind), but the opening scene in this one really drove home that the Winchesters are as dangerous as what they hunt; (2) I want to see badass hunters for a change; and (3) I liked the concept of the serial killer human.
suzee51
# suzee51 2012-05-23 20:13
Slash Fiction
Born-Again Identity
Hello Cruel World
Meet the New Boss
Defending Your Life
The Mentalists
How to Win Friends & Influence Monsters
Death's Door
Time After Time
Survival of the Fittest
Repo Man
Reading is Fundamental
Adventures in Babysitting
Slice Girls
Time for a Wedding
Girl with the Dungeons & Dragons Tattoo
There Will Be Blood
Party On, Garth
Of Grave Importance
Out With the Old
Girl Next Door
Plucky Pennywhistle
Shut Up, Dr. Phil

I can hear people screaming: "Oh God, no!" but I haven't agreed with a lot of the takes on this season. Also, sometimes there may be a particular scene that I enjoy if not the entire episode.
KELLY
# KELLY 2012-05-23 20:24
Death’s Door
Hello Cruel World
Meet The Boss
How to Win Friends and Influence Monster
Slash Fiction
Born Again Identity
Survival of the Fittest
Time After Time
Reading is Fundamental
Repo Man
The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magic Menagerie
The Slice Girls
The Girl Next Door
There Will Be Blood
Out With the Old
Of Grave Importance
Adventure’s in Babysitting
Season 7 Time for a Wedding
Party On Garth
Shut Up Dr Phil
The Mentalist
Defending Your Life

I reserve the right to completely changed my mind at any time up this is my first pass. LOL. I have an easier time rating the individual 1-10. And some like Party On Garth I kind of wanted to rate higher because of one scene. Or BAI I loved but it rate it even higher because to the LACK of one scene.
MisterGlass
# MisterGlass 2012-05-23 21:09
1. Meet The New Boss
2. Slash Fiction
3. Hello, Cruel World
4. Death’s Door
5. Repo Man
6. The Mentalists
7. How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
8. Party On, Garth
9. The Girl Next Door
10. The Born-Again Identity
11. Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
12. Survival of The Fittest
13. Reading Is Fundamental
14. Time After Time
15. Out With The Old
16. Shut Up Dr. Phil
17. There Will Be Blood
18. Adventures in Babysitting
19. Of Grave Importance
20. The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
21. The Slice Girls
22. Season 7: Time For A Wedding
23. Defending Your Life

This is a tough season! The first three and last three were easy, everything else in the middle could go up or down two spots, they are so close.
MetamorphicRocks
# MetamorphicRocks 2012-05-23 23:51
1. Hello Cruel World
2. Meet the New Boss
3. Time After Time
4. Repo Man
5. The Born-Again Identitiy
6. Reading is Fundamental
7. Survival of the Fittest
8. Death's Door
9. Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
10. The Mentalists
11. Slash Fiction
12. The Girl Next Door
13. Of Grave Importance
14. There Will Be Blood
15. Slice Girls
16. How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
17. Party On, Garth
18. Out With the Old
19. Defending Your Life
20. Adventures in Babysitting
21. The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
22. Season 7, Time for a Wedding
23. Shut up, Dr. Phil

It really is interesting to see how different everyone's rankings are. This is very indicative of why there are so many great discussions on this board as each episode speaks differently to different people!
rmoats8621
# rmoats8621 2012-05-24 00:17
1. Death’s Door
2. Hello, Cruel World
3. Slash Fiction
4. Meet The New Boss
5. The Born-Again Identity
6. The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
7. Survival of The Fittest
8. Reading Is Fundamental
9. How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
10. Time After Time
11. Repo Man
12. There Will Be Blood
13. The Slice Girls
14. The Girl Next Door
15. Adventures in Babysitting
16. Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
17. Out With The Old
18. Shut Up Dr. Phil
19. The Mentalists
20. Party On, Garth
21. Of Grave Importance
22. Season 7: Time For A Wedding
23. Defending Your Life
Tim the Enchanter
# Tim the Enchanter 2012-05-24 02:18
This is my gut reaction but in my defense my gut has only woken up about 20 minutes ago so it is completely subject to change (and probably will when I look at it with my glasses on).

It took WAY longer than five minutes, mainly because I couldn't remember which episode names related to which episode. Next season I hope they go back to the 'The one with the mad vegan vampire' or 'The one where Sam lost his other shoe'.

Anyway:
1. Hello Cruel World
2. Death’s Door
3. Meet the New Boss
4. The Born Again Identity
5. Repo Man
6. Plucky Pennywhistles Magical Menagerie
7. Survival of the Fittest
8. How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
9. Slash Fiction
10. There Will Be Blood
11. Reading is Fundamental
12. Out with the Old
13. The Girl Next Door
14. Adventures in Babysitting
15. Of Grave Importance
16. The Slice Girls
17. The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragon Tattoo
18. Time after Time
19. Defending your Life
20. Party on, Garth
21. Shut Up, Doctor Phil
22. Time for A Wedding





23. The Mentalists
Sharon
# Sharon 2012-05-24 02:39
Some I didnt watch so I will try to rank those I did.

1) Hello Cruel World

2) Meet The New Boss

3) Plucky Pennywhistles Magical Menagerie

4) Born Again Identity

5) Time after Time

6) Slash Fiction

7) Repo Man

8 The Girl Next Door

9) Adventures in Babysitting Land

10) Shut up Dr Phil

11) Defending Your Life

And I cant rank Time for a Wedding because I have no idea what it was :o
milly
# milly 2012-05-24 03:59
1. Hello Cruel World
2. Repo Man
3. The Born-Again Identitiy
4. Meet the New Boss
5. Death's Door
6. Time After Time
7. Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
8. The Mentalists
9. Slash Fiction
10. How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
11. The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
12. Survival of the Fittest
13. There Will Be Blood
14. Slice Girls
15. Reading is Fundamental
16.. Of Grave Importance
17. Party On, Garth
18. Out With the Old
19. Defending Your Life
20. Adventures in Babysitting
21. The Girl Next Door
22. Season 7, Time for a Wedding
23. Shut up, Dr. Phil
Karen
# Karen 2012-05-24 06:00
Meet The New Boss
Hello Cruel World
Slash Fiction
How Two Win Friends and Influence Monsters
Death’s Door
Survival of the Fittest
The Born-Again Identity
Time After Time
Plucky Pennywhistles Magical Menagerie
Repo Man
Of Grave Importance
Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
Reading Is Fundamental
There Will Be Blood
Party On, Garth
The Mentalists
The Girl Next Door
Out With The Old
Shut Up Dr. Phil
Adventures In Babysitting
The Slice Girls
Defending Your Life
Season 7, Time For A Wedding

Well I did it all under 5 minutes! Of course this list could all change by tomorrow....dep ending on my mood ;-)
BeccaB
# BeccaB 2012-05-24 07:09
Time After Time
Death's Door
Slash Fiction
How to Win Friends And Influence Monsters
Repo Man
The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragon Tatoo
Survival of the Fittest
Aventures in Babysitting
Reading is Fubdamental
The Mentalists
There Will Be Blood
Hello Cruel World
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
Party On Garth
The Girl Next Door
Meet the Boss
Shut Up, Dr. Phil
Out with The Old
The Born-Again Idenity
Of Grave Importance
The Slice Girls
Season 7: Time for a Wedding
Defending Your Life
Reetu
# Reetu 2012-05-24 08:43
Hi Alice nice exercise. My list depending upon enjoyment, excited pace and of-course Sam n Dean scope in episode (along with supporting cast)

1)Meet The New Boss
2)Death’s Door
3)Hello, Cruel World
4)The Born-Again Identity
5)Repo Man
6)Slash Fiction
7)Reading Is Fundamental
8)The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
9)How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
10)Time After Time
11)Survival of The Fittest
12)There Will Be Blood
13)Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
14)Out With The Old
15)The Mentalists
16)The Slice Girls
17)Of Grave Importance
18)Season 7: Time For A Wedding
19)Shut Up Dr. Phil
20)Party On, Garth
21)Defending Your Life
22)Adventures in Babysitting
23)The Girl Next Door (but i very much liked Colin ford as young Sam in here)
Sylvie
# Sylvie 2012-05-24 10:16
Wow, that was really hard. I got it done in 5 min., but then I realized I forgot 2! So it took me a while to figure that out. I reserve the right to change my mind in the next 5 minutes. The top & bottom ones were easy, but man, everything in the middle was difficult. Okay, here goes:

Slash Fiction
Hello Cruel World
Meet the New Boss
Death's Door
Survival of the Fittest
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
Time After Time
Of Grave Importance
There Will Be Blood
Repo Man
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
Born Again Identity
Girl With the Dungeons & Dragon Tattoo
Reading Is Fundamental
The Mentalists
The Girl Next Door
Out With the Old
Party On Garth
Slice Girls
Adventures in Babysitting
Shut Up Dr. Phil
Season 7: Time For a Wedding
Defending Your Life
Samara
# Samara 2012-05-24 11:17
Death’s Door
The Born-Again Identity
Repo Man
The Mentalists
Hello, Cruel World
Slash Fiction
Meet the New Boss
Time After Time
The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
Party On, Garth
Of Grave Importance
Out With The Old
Reading is Fundamental
Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
There Will Be Blood
The Girl Next Door
The Slice Girls
Survival of the Fittest
How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
Adventures in Babysitting
Shut Up, Dr. Phil
Defending Your Life
Season 7: Time for a Wedding
Bevie
# Bevie 2012-05-24 11:37
This is difficult as the ones my brain tells me I should like for critical reasons are not always the ones I pick for pure enjoyment of the episodes. For instance "Death's Door" which was critically the best, is down near the bottom of the enjoyment list, as I could never enjoy Bobby dying ever!

I'm breaking the rules with two lists then. And not all the episodes will be on either one. So there!

Critical Best 8)

Death's Door
Survival of the Fittest
Meet the New Boss
Hello, Cruel World
The Born-Again Identity
Time After Time
Slash Fiction
Repo Man
There Will Be Blood
Reading is Fundamental
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo

Critical Worst :-x

Defending Your Life
Season 7: Time for a Wedding

Enjoyably Best :P

Slash Fiction
Survival of the Fittest
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Girl Next Door
Meet the New Boss
Hello, Cruel World
Party On, Garth
Slice Girls
There Will Be Blood
Reading is Fundamental
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
Time After Time
The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo

Least Enjoyable :-?

Death's Door :cry:
Defending Your Life :o
Season 7: Time for a Wedding :-x

The order could change in the next ten minutes, but
there it is for now. The worst and least won't change.
fanotheboyz
# fanotheboyz 2012-05-24 20:38
Here goes:
1 Time After Time
2 Death's Door
3 Meet the New Boss
4 Girl with the Dungeons....
5 Hello Cruel World
6 How to win Friends...
7 Born Again Identity
8 Reading is Fun...
9 Slash Fiction
10 Slice Girls
11 Party on Garth
12 Out with the Old
13 Plucky
14 The Mentalists
15 The Girl Next Door
16 Adventures in Baby...
17 Time for a Wedding
18 Shut up Dr. Phil
19 Of Grave Importance
20 There Will be Blood
21 Repo Man
22 Survival of the Fittest
23 Defending your Life

The top 2 and bottom 2 are solid. The others could change around a little.
kaj
# kaj 2012-05-24 22:00
Hello, Cruel World
Meet The New Boss
Slash Fiction
Time After Time
Death’s Door
Repo Man
Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
The Mentalists
Reading Is Fundamental
The Born-Again Identity
The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
Out With The Old
Survival of The Fittest
Adventures in Babysitting
There Will Be Blood
The Girl Next Door
Shut Up Dr. Phil
The Slice Girls
How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
Of Grave Importance
Defending Your Life
Party On, Garth
Season 7: Time For A Wedding


The last two are interchangeable . Hehe.. I like this game!
yam26
# yam26 2012-05-24 22:45
Meet the New Boss
Survival of the Fittest
Hello Cruel World
The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
How to win friends and Influence Monsters
The Mentalists
The Borne-Again Identity
Slash Fiction

The
Repo Man
Deaths Door
Of grave Importance
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
Out With the Old
The Slice Girls
Time after Time
Season 7: Time for a Wedding
Shut up Dr. Phil
Party on Garth
There Will be Blood
The Girl Next Door
Defending Your Life
Adventures in Babysitting
yam26
# yam26 2012-05-24 22:54
I realised I forgot reading is fundamental, would say it goes under Born again Identity. That was fun :)
Kazkriz
# Kazkriz 2012-05-24 22:58
Hello cruel world
Survival of the fittest
meet the new boss
Death's doors
Slash fiction
How to win Friends and influence monsters
The girl with the dungeon and dragon tattoo
the born again identity
plucky penny whistle magical menagerie
time after time after time
reading is fundamental
repo man
there will be blood
adventures in babysitting
slice girls
out with the old
party on garth
season 7 time for a wedding
shut up dr. Phill
the girl next door
the mentalist
defending your life
reading is fundamental
Corynne
# Corynne 2012-05-25 05:45
Hello cruel world
Survival of the fittest
Slash fiction
Deaths door
Plucky penny whistles
Time after time
Mentalists
Adventures in babysitting
Meet the new boss
Born again identity
There will be blood
Reading is fundamental
Girl w dungeons...
How to win friends...
Grave importance
Party on Garth
Slice girls
Repo man
Shut up Dr Phil
Girl next door
Defending your life
Time for a wedding
Out with the old

Every episode has outstanding moments and to number them is so dificult when every episode is better than anything else I watch.... nothing is as good as any single episode of our great show
vivian
# vivian 2012-05-25 07:44
1) Meet the New Boss
2) The Born Again Identity
3) Hello Cruel World
4) Reading is Fundamental
5) Death's Door
6) Survival of the Fittest
7) Repo Man
8) There will Be Blood
9) Slash Fiction
10) How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
11) PPMM
12) Time after Time
13) The Girl with The Dungeons and Dragons Tatoo
14) Of Grave Importance
15) The Mentalist
16) Party On, Garth
17) The Girl Next Door
18) Out with the World
19) The Slice Girls
20) S7, Time for a Weeding
21) Shut up Dr. Phil
22) Defending Your Life
23) Adventures in Babyssiting

But the only I really didn't like was the last one, AIB.
JuliaG
# JuliaG 2012-05-25 13:34
1. Hello Cruel World
2. Meet the New Boss
3. Death's Door
4. Slash Fiction
5. Born Again Identity
6. Repo Man
7. Plucky…
8. Reading is Fundamental
9. Survival of the Fittest (because of the cliffhanger)
10. Time after Time
11. How to win Friend and Influence Monsters.
12. the Girl Next Door
13. The Girls with the Dungeons and Dragon Tatoo

The next group is all together, as I honestly don't remember what they were about:

14. Of Grave importance
15. Out with the Old
16. There will be Blood
17. Shut up, Dr. Phil

Bottom Six:

18. Adventures in Babysitting
19. Slice Girls
20. Party on, Garth
21. Defending your Life
22. S7, Time for a Wedding

WAY DOWN:

23. The Mentalist
nancyL
# nancyL 2012-05-25 13:57
This season started with such promise, and then it got flushed down the toilet. Here's hoping for season eight.

Here goes:

The good:

1. Plunky Pennywhistle
2. Slash Fiction (except for the Amy melodrama reprise)
3. Time after Time
4. Grave Importance
5. Out with the Old
6. Meet the New Boss
7. Hello Cruel World
8. The Mentalists (finally an end to the Amy melodrama)
9. Death's Door
10.Repo Man
11 Born again ID
12.Reading is Fundamental
13.There will be blood

the bad:

14.How to win friends
15.Adventures in Babysitting
16.Survival of the fittest (sorry, redeeming quality was Impala porn, otherwise it was kinda slow)

and the just plain ugly:

17.Girl next door (the beginning of the Amy melodrama)
18.Defending your life (part two of the Amy melodrama, why does Dean feel guilty?)
19.Shut up, Dr. Phil (Spike & Cordy 'standing' in for Sam & Dean, we get it)
20.Time for a Wedding (one word:Becky)
21.The Slice Girls (more Amy melodrama, w/o Amy)
22.Party on, Garth (one word:Garth, a whole episode of him was too much)
23.Girl with a Dragon tattoo (sorry, I did not find Charlie, or whatever her name was, endearing)
Blue
# Blue 2012-05-25 18:14
Great

Slash Fiction
Meet The New Boss
Hello, Cruel World
Time After Time
The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
Reading Is Fundamental
Death’s Door

Good

Adventures in Babysitting
Repo Man
The Mentalists
Survival of The Fittest
Defending Your Life
Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters

Bad

The Born-Again Identity
Party On, Garth
Out With The Old
The Slice Girls
Of Grave Importance
The Girl Next Door

Awful

There Will Be Blood
Shut Up Dr. Phil
Season 7: Time For A Wedding
Debbie Harb
# Debbie Harb 2012-05-27 10:25
Meet The New Boss
Reading Is Fundamental
The Born-Again Identity
Death’s Door
Time After Time (time travel always gets me)
Season 7: Time For A Wedding
How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
The Mentalists
Repo Man
Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie (much better than I thought it would be)
The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
Survival of The Fittest
Slash Fiction
Shut Up Dr. Phil (Loved seeing James)
There Will Be Blood
Hello, Cruel World
The Girl Next Door
Of Grave Importance
Out With The Old
The Slice Girls
Defending Your Life
Adventures in Babysitting
Party On, Garth (did enjoy Dean's katana blessing)

When reviewing everyone's lists it easy to tell who that Becky isn't appreciated by the majority. I always enjoy her appearances and guess that makes me the minority.
Ally
# Ally 2012-05-27 12:51
1. Meet The New Boss
2. Death’s Door
3. Hello, Cruel World
4. Reading Is Fundamental
5. How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
6. Repo Man
7. The Born-Again Identity
8. Survival of The Fittest
9. The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
10. Time After Time
11. There Will Be Blood
12. Of Grave Importance
13. Slash Fiction
14. Out With The Old
15. The Girl Next Door
16. Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
17. Shut Up Dr. Phil
18. The Mentalists
19. Party On, Garth
20. Season 7: Time For A Wedding
21. Adventures in Babysitting
22. Defending Your Life
23. The Slice Girls
Supernarttu
# Supernarttu 2012-05-27 14:04
Hmm.. I think I managed in about 5 mins. Just had to look up some of the names so I'd remember what it was all about.

So, here's my list. I think the order might be quite accurate overall regarding my opinion of this season... Then again, ask me later... :D


1. Meet The New Boss
2. Hello, Cruel World
3. Repo Man
4. Slash Fiction
5. Death’s Door
6. The Born-Again Identity
7. Time After Time
8. Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
9. Survival of The Fittest
10. Of Grave Importance
11. How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
12. Out With The Old
13. The Girl Next Door
14. The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15. Adventures in Babysitting
16. Reading Is Fundamental
17.There Will Be Blood
17 The Slice Girls
19.Party On, Garth
20.Defending Your Life


21.Shut Up Dr. Phil
22. Season 7: Time For A Wedding
23. The Mentalists

Gotta say, the last 3 sucked so bad, I don't want to think about it...
Supernarttu
# Supernarttu 2012-05-27 14:05
18 The Slice Girls... Oops :)
PENNY JAIME
# PENNY JAIME 2012-05-27 16:40
Interesting to see everyone opinions. My fav, SLASH FICTION, made most peoples top 10; but I also loved Defending Your Life (probably the flashbacks), & most people didn't care for that one. I liked the take on Repo Man as well. Never thought of it as seeing how dangerous Dean & Sam can be. Guess I take that character trait for granted. Thanks for sharing everyone
eilf
# eilf 2012-05-28 16:34
The Born-Again Identity
Meet The New Boss
Hello, Cruel World
Survival of The Fittest
The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
Reading Is Fundamental
Adventures in Babysitting
There Will Be Blood
Time After Time
Of Grave Importance
The Girl Next Door
Defending Your Life
Repo Man
Death’s Door
Party On, Garth
How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters
Season 7: Time For A Wedding
The Slice Girls
Out With The Old
Slash Fiction
The Mentalists
Shut Up Dr. Phil
Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
Bamboo24
# Bamboo24 2012-08-09 14:08
Just saw this. Here are mine.

1. How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
2. Slash Fiction
3. Death’s Door
4. Hello Cruel World
5. Meet The New Boss
6. The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
7. Repo Man
8. Party On, Garth
9. Time For A Wedding
10. The Slice Girls

11. Defending Your Life
12. There Will Be Blood
13. The Mentalists
14. Of Grave Importance
15. Time After Time
16. The Girl Next Door
17. Plucky Pennywhistle’ s Magical Menagerie
18. Adventures in Babysitting
19. Shut Up, Dr. Phil
20. Survival of The Fittest
21. Reading Is Fundamental
22. The Born-Again Identity
23. Out With The Old

I think I'm the only one who put "Time For A Wedding" in the top ten. [Shrug] I thought it was hilarious (though Becky is annoying and I can only handle her in small doses).

"Slice Girls" made the top ten because I thought it was well-done, albeit pointless - especially considering all the grief the boys had been dealing with all season.

I detested "Out With The Old." The Leviathans in that episode ruined it for me, and it was not well paced. Ugh.

"Born-Again Identity" frustrates me, because it could have made my top-ten easily, but I felt it was extremely poorly written.

"Defending Your Life," despite being a generally wasted opportunity, is still an episode I'll re-watch.