Created on Wednesday, 09 November 2011 00:17
Written by Alice Jester
is an extraordinary show. We all know this. It inspires a passion, an excitement, a fervor like few others. Mo became a huge fan of the show in season four. Sheâ€™s been nothing but a big friend to Supernatural
and given it a nationally recognized critical spotlight. Yes, that love has gone a bit sour, especially after season six, but she really does care about the show. All of her tough criticisms of late, theyâ€™re out of genuine concern and love for Supernatural
. This isnâ€™t me guessing. Weâ€™ve had recent conversations. Her latest review is very controversial, but just the way itâ€™s delivered, it should prove how much emotional investment she has in Supernatural
After reading some of the comments left on her review, I just wanted to cry. Mo is a very good person and doesnâ€™t deserve this crap. No reviewer does. Some forget their humanity when hiding behind a computer. These comments were mechanisms for taking personal potshots and criticizing harshly her integrity as a critic, even though she has years of solid work ahead of this. I recognize it may not have been the most professional review, but why is she not allowed to make a passionate plea for a show that she loves? Why is she not allowed to do something out of turn once in a while? Maybe itâ€™s not her normal behavior, and Iâ€™ll admit it was emotionally charged, but did anyone think that perhaps thereâ€™s a reason behind the frustration? Benefit of the doubt doesnâ€™t seem to exist in this online world. People just love to trash. Most fans were so receptive to the attention she brought the show when the comments were good. Quite frankly, some of these angry fans scare me.
I know how it is though. I had an issue like Mo once, although on a much much smaller scale. I wrote a off the cuff, misguided review on â€œSex and Violenceâ€ on my way home from New York Comic Con which pissed off a huge contingent of Dean fans. I wrote that review almost three years ago. People to this day still throw that in my face. Once you piss off some Supernatural
fans, youâ€™re scarred for life. Also, Iâ€™ve had writers come and go here with great frustrations because Supernatural
stopped being the show they fell in love with. Breaking up with a show is hard. It really is like losing a love in a relationship.
I doubt youâ€™ll see Mo writing another thing about Supernatural
. Who knows, maybe down the road in season nine or something like that. I know many of you will say â€œgood riddanceâ€ but not I. Sheâ€™s been a fantastic colleague in this fandom and been very good for our show. She may be a professional critic, but sheâ€™s also a fan girl too. Iâ€™m very, very sad if we lose her and the wisdom she brought to her analysis of Supernatural
The Mentalists - http://www.aoltv.com/2011/11/05/supernatural-season-7-episode-7-recap/
Slash Fiction - http://www.aoltv.com/2011/10/29/supernatural-season-7-episode-6-recap/
In case you missed it too, here's her article on "Tough Love For Supernatural"
which stemmed for our conversation at Chicon along with Lynn and Kathy at Fangasm. I'm quoted in there directly and stand by every word.
As for the other links, Gerry Weaver is the new Supernatural
reviewer for Blogcritics (taking the slot I vacated), and I couldnâ€™t be happier. She has a nice, fresh view of the show thatâ€™s sorely needed. Read this reply on my recent review of â€œThe Mentalists.â€ Talk about a refreshing POV.
Here are the links for â€œSlash Fictionâ€ and â€œThe Mentalistsâ€, as well as a â€œcheckupâ€ on Supernatural
season seven so far. All good stuff!
â€œThe Mentalistsâ€ - http://blogcritics.org/video/article/tv-review-supernatural-the-mentalists/
â€œSlash Fictionâ€ - http://blogcritics.org/video/article/tv-review-supernatural-slash-fiction/
Seventh Season Checkup - http://blogcritics.org/video/article/supernaturals-seventh-season-check-up/
Tina Charles of TV Guide calls â€œSlash Fictionâ€ her favorite of season seven so far (except for the last scene). She liked â€œThe Mentalistsâ€ but is hoping so see some more mythology episodes soon. I canâ€™t disagree with that!
â€œThe Mentalistsâ€ - http://www.tvguide.com/tvshows/supernatural-2011/episode-7-season-7/the-mentalists/192272
â€œSlash Fictionâ€ - http://www.tvguide.com/tvshows/supernatural-2011/episode-6-season-7/slash-fiction/192272
Hereâ€™s Nicoleâ€™s reviews on Salted and Burned. I got to spend some time with Nicole in Chicago and I think sheâ€™s got an amazing mind for analysis and TV criticism. She certainly knows her X-Files
â€œThe Mentalistsâ€ - http://saltedandburned.com/2011/11/ramblings-on-episode-7x07-the-mentalist-spoilers/
â€œSlash Fictionâ€ - http://saltedandburned.com/2011/11/ramblings-on-episode-7x06-slash-fiction-spoilers/
I also got to meet SweetOnDean in Chicago too! She has a great review for â€œThe Mentalistsâ€ and shows in detail why she loved this episode so much.
Clarissa from TV Overmind loved the season one feel of â€œThe Mentalistsâ€ and liked â€œSlash Fictionâ€ although found the ending disappointing.
â€œThe Mentalistsâ€ - http://tvovermind.zap2it.com/supernatural-tv-news/supernatural-season-7-episode-7-the-mentalists-review/102880
â€œSlash Fictionâ€ - http://tvovermind.zap2it.com/supernatural-tv-news/supernatural-review-season-7-episode-6-slash-fiction-recap/101496
Bekah from Support Supernatural had some great things to say as well about both episodes.
â€œThe Mentalistsâ€ - http://www.supportsupernatural.com/s7e7review.htm
â€œSlash Fictionâ€ - http://www.supportsupernatural.com/s7e6review.htm
Iâ€™ve been negligent in sharing this link for a while. Check out the always entertaining â€œStream of Consciousnessâ€ from Gaelicspirit.
â€œThe Mentalistsâ€ - http://gaelicspirit.livejournal.com/125364.html
â€œSlash Fictionâ€ - http://gaelicspirit.livejournal.com/124765.html
You know, this is terrible for me to lose track, but someone here on this site in some comment shared a link about someone who does visual type reviews on Livejournal. If anyone knows what Iâ€™m talking about, please share the link here. Iâ€™d love to check those out and recommend for the future.
Share any links I missed here! I know there are plenty. All opinions are welcome too about anything else Iâ€™ve said here too, but please, keep it civil. Iâ€™d like to see all of us put this ugliness behind us and have a fresh start.
People in this conversation