The Winchester Family Business Supernatural Season 7 Fan Awards - Page 5
Tuesday, 19 June 2012 21:18 | Last Updated on Wednesday, 20 June 2012 21:03 | Written by Alice Jester | 
| 
| 
Saddest Scene
Winner
Bobby’s final memory - Happily watching Sam and Dean argue over snack food, "Death’s Door"
Runner Up
Bobby’s death scene - Calling the boys “idgits” before passing on, "Death’s Door"
It’s a clean sweep for “Death’s Door” and that’s hardly a surprise. That episode pretty much ravaged Kleenex supplies everywhere. The entire hour left us all complete emotional wrecks, so picking any one scene is probably a fruitless exercise. However, I do agree with the masses, his final memory of Sam and Dean just had something more for me. It was the brothers in closer times, before both went to Hell. I wish we still could see them like that at times. They even brought back Sam’s old shirt. No wonder Bobby was so fond of that memory!
| < Prev | Next > |
|---|
Comments
That guest star category really was the hardest. Even if Mark Pellegrino won it hands down, I'm pretty sure it's because in most people's minds he was just a nose ahead of all the other guest stars they also wanted to vote for. That is to say, it wasn't close in the poll but it was close in our minds.
MAYBE I WILL MATCH UP BETTER WITH THE EDITIORS CHOICES. HOPE SO. FEELS LIKE A TEST I MADE A B- ON. NOT USED TO THAT.
I SHALL SEE.
PS. BECKY JUST DOES NOT BOTHER ME LIKE SOME OF YOU. SHE IS A COMPOSITE OF ALL THE FANS. NOT JUST 1 TYPE. TO EACH HIS OWN. PEACE
The one that disagreed with me the most, was the Impala winning for Badass scene. I wanted so badly to vote for it, but didn't, because in that moment Dean was not driving, Meg was. I admit I would have voted for it, if he had been.
I love Sera Gamble's episodes (well almost all of them) but she never quite "got" the Impala, in my opinion. I can't think of a single scene in any of her scripts where it was featured in any meaningful way.
Taking away the Impala all season long, and not having Sam be the one with Dean when they recovered her, and not having them clearly shown driving... was very disappointing and went a long way to leaving me feeling dissatisfied with season 7. All season I waited for a Sam & Dean bonding moment with their home, the Impala. It deserved a much bigger fuss. So the Badass scene was a disappointment to me.
Laurie, I have to disagree with this statement. One of my favorite Impala moments ever is the scene at the end of "Fresh Blood" where Dean decides it is time to "show his little brother the ropes" and has Sam do the repairs to the car.
Another favorite scene is in another Sera ep (and one that also included Gordon Walker) -- the scene at the beginning of "Bloodlust" where Dean is driving the newly-restored Impala while AC/DC's "Back in Black" is playing. Where Sam says "If you two want to get a room (referring to the Impala), just let me know, Dean" and Dean responds "Don't listen to him, baby. He just doesn't understand us."
I also love the scene at the end where Sam and Dean have this wonderful conversation over the roof of the Impala:
Dean: No, but every instinct told me to. I was going to kill her. I was going to kill them all.
Sam: Yeah Dean, but you didn't. And that's what matters.
Dean: Yeah. Well, 'cause you're a pain in my ass.
Sam: Guess I might have to stick around to be a pain in the ass then.
Dean: Thanks.
Sam: Don't mention it.
and then it ends a long shot of the Impala driving off down a dirt road.
I know there are probably more, but these are the ones that immediately came to mind when I saw your post.
I'm not shocked at all by 'Dean killing Amy' not being the worst ending -- I honestly never got what the fuss was about, either about Dean's actions or that the consequences of it were a sub plot carried through several episodes.
These were fun. I'm glad we got the chance to vote and I hope we do it all again for season 8!!
I voted for Julian Richlings, not Mark P., because I don't like how the Show has turned Luci into a whiner and seemingly bugging what he wants to be his best friend. Mark P. is a good actor, it's how they turned the character into anything but scary.
Looking forward to the editors' review!
the maligned "Hammer of the Gods". Maybe I'm just weird. Other than that, I'm ok with the other choices although I do prefer Death over Lucifer. I am over Luci now.
I know it's not a test but sometimes it felt like it. hehehe You won't believe how much I love tests and pools.
I still think Shut Up Dr, Phil is useless. It can be written better by bringing up a comparative case of not a pair of warlock in a bitching contest. i don't really get what's so funny and what's the irony in the episode.
I get the irony of Defending your life, and I like how the essence of The Mentalist. How they psychic are mirroring Sam and Dean, kinda. There are lot's to digest in the epi.
Time for a wedding is a close second for me to the worst epi. It's saving grace is the appearance of Crowley and the Wicked Crossroad Demon. I like how the actor portrayed him as a villain.
Death Door is well written but I won't put it in The Best Episode. The script is good, I guess. If the title of the show is The Singers Supernaturals. Where Sam & Dean are adopted by Bobby ever since their mom died.
It's not that I dislike Bobby. I like Bobby's character so much. And it's a good thing that they acknowledge a well loved and loyal character with an entire episode dedicated for him. (Two episodes been dedicated to Bobby, Weekend at Bobby's). But putting that episode for the best episode in a SUPERNATURAL story in which SAM and DEAN is the center of the story is ... blegh.
IF, it's only if, the Show started only in season 6 and 7, regardless of the previous history between the brothers. Then, it can be the best episode. But there are lots and lots history for 5 seasons long before this season.
It's ironic that the best episode of the season is the episode that depicting the life struggle of a supporting character. What's that saying for the writer this season?
Just my opinion. Others can disagree.
RSS feed for comments to this post